Electrical Engineering Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for electronics and electrical engineering professionals, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I am working on a prototype using existing breakout boards from open source hardware manufacturers (Sparkfun, Adafruit, Teensy etc...). Everything is going great!

I am at the stage where I'd like to start designing my own PCB in order to consolidate the components into a single board.

Right now, each breakout board is powered by the same LiPo battery, so it seems that I might be able to simply use the existing schematics from each board and simply combine them onto a single board, where each "component group" draws its power from the battery and shares the ground... analogous to the manner in which the individual breakout boards are currently wired up.

Is this as simple as it seems, and is it common practice for beginning circuit builders to take this approach without implementing KVL, KCL, and Thevenin node calculations, etc...

Thanks for any advice on this.

share|improve this question
2  
Short answer yes, long answer try to combine what you can. In general a breakout board contains more than you need and if you understand what's going on with each, you can simplify your schematic greatly. – mcmiln Feb 4 at 17:37
    
I would have thought you should look at ways of optimising the electronics rather than just duplicating the development boards – Paul Edwards-Shea Feb 4 at 18:22
    
In the spirit of "one step at a time" I think I'll attack that next...but thanks for the heads up. – Aaron Feb 4 at 18:33
    
Since I'm a newbie, I think I'll iterate to a working solution...optimizing where I can (as far as my understanding will take me) after I have a duplicate working prototype. Thanks for the heads up. – Aaron Feb 4 at 18:38
    
FWIW, even pros use this approach when doing system-level design. The only exceptions are: you're doing sensitive analog circuitry, you're dealing with clock speeds above 100MHz or you're embedding RF circuits into your circuit. These 3 reasons are why modules are so popular because they've isolated the analog/RF/high-speed circuitry from the rest of your system so that you can do plug-and-play circuit design. – slebetman Feb 5 at 5:03

There's nothing wrong with that basic approach. Chances are the PCBs that you are using were themselves adapted from typical application circuits for each of the parts.

Speaking of which, I think it's better to look up (and read and understand) the datasheets for each the parts before you blindly transfer the schematics to your own board. You'll have to find exact part numbers, pick packages and so on anyway. The components and the schematics may not include enough information even to just purchase new parts.

share|improve this answer
    
Thanks! I'll keep that in mind as I move forward and have the datasheets handy. – Aaron Feb 4 at 18:33

Yes, you can probably do what you want. You copy the circuits, but tie the power of each together and use a common ground. As you say, that's basically how you have them wired now.

A few things to watch out for:

  1. Make sure the battery can still handle the current required of all the circuits together.

  2. Think about the resulting ground currents carefully. By putting the circuits together, there is more opportunity for one to make noise that will be a problem for another.

  3. You may need more capacitance on the overall supply. The supply is a obvious path for noise from one circuit feeding into another. Extra capacitance on the supply will help. You may also need to do more local filtering.

share|improve this answer

With the caveat that you've not mentioned at all what set of COTS dev boards you've put together, so this reply is equally general: If you're taking proven dev boards & their schematics, and you've successfully glued them together to do what you need, then yes, it is as simple as amalgamating them onto the one schematic and PCB, and perhaps even stripping out bits you don't need (ideally tested on the dev boards).

Doubtless there is still much that can go wrong and learning to be had, but that's expected, right? :)

share|improve this answer
    
Great! Thanks for the quick reply! – Aaron Feb 4 at 17:10

Yeah, if you hook them up on the bench then you can just do the same thing on a PCB and combine all of the circuits. One thing to pay attention to when combining circuits since most of them are IC's nowadays is voltage levels and inputs. You can find the digital levels in the datasheet of the IC's. With digital circuits you need to make sure the logic levels "match up". A 5V CMOS output is not necessarily compatible with LVTTL. With digital circuits pay attention to the switching levels and currents. If you are trying to drive multiple inputs with an output then you need to worry about the current that the digital output can source to each digital input (if its too much it won't switch on all the way). Its a good idea just to get familiar with logic levels and input and output impedances. This is a simplification but if you don't understand start googling some of this stuff (logic level, fanout ect).

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.