Take the 2-minute tour ×
Electrical Engineering Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for electronics and electrical engineering professionals, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

There's a paper called "Simplified Analysis of PWM Converters Using Model of PWM Switch (part 1)" by Vatché Vorpérian which introduces a "PWM switch" to model the switch and diode in a switching voltage converter.

I'm following along happily while he derives its properties and then he uses the model to get DC characteristics for a boost converter. This is where I started struggling, so I thought I'd try to simulate the thing in SPICE (well, Gnucap) to see if I could spot what I was doing wrong. This didn't help much...

Here's a circuit diagram (which is correct, since it appears pretty much verbatim in his paper): The circuit diagram

D is the duty ratio. Here is the netlist I was trying to use to simulate things:

* Boost converter with PWM model

.parameter D=0.6
.parameter vg=10

.subckt tx p1 p2 s1 s2 PARAM: N=10
FP p1 p2 VS {1/N}
ES s1 int1 p1 p2 {N}
VS s2 int1 DC 0
RLnk s2 p2 1M
.ends tx

Vg 1 0 DC {vg}
Rp 1 2 0.1
X1 2 3 4 3 tx N={D}
Vdummy 4 0 DC 0

RL 3 0 1k

.print dc v(1) v(2) v(3) i(RL) i(Rp) i(Vdummy)
.dc

The results are rather unexpected!

* Boost converter with PWM model 
#           v(1)       v(2)       v(3)       i(RL)      i(Rp)      i(Vdummy) 
 0.         10.        10.004    -15.006    -0.015006  -0.037514  -0.022508  

Can anyone spot something I've done wrong? In particular, the current seems to be flowing the wrong way, which seems pretty bizarre. I tried out the tx transformer subcircuit and convinced myself it worked, but I may have made a mistake.

share|improve this question
    
For anyone coming across this question: as Art pointed out below, I have the wrong gain for FP (should be N, not 1/N). Also, the transformer gain is the wrong way round: for a boost converter as written here, I needed 1/D instead of D (otherwise the voltage just gets inverted and current flows backwards in the secondary loop!) –  Rupert Swarbrick May 13 '12 at 8:00
    
sigh No, in fact I was still being stupid. I misread Art's comment (which was correct). Es should have had gain 1/N to simulate an N:1 turn ideal transformer. (And then D rather than 1/D is correct) –  Rupert Swarbrick May 13 '12 at 8:14
add comment

2 Answers

up vote 1 down vote accepted

I think the gain of Es should be 1/N, not N, to correctly model the N:1 "DC transformer". (The "reverse" current transfer ratio should be the same as the "forward" voltage transfer ratio.)

Also, although it doesn't matter in this case, in the SPICEs I've seen, your RLnk=1M would be a 1 milliohm resistor short from p2 to s2; a value of 1MEG would give 1 megohm. (Maybe your program uses a different convention?)

share|improve this answer
    
Oops. Also, thanks for the catch about RLnk: I'd used 1G and then wasn't concentrating when I went back to (not quite) 1Meg. –  Rupert Swarbrick May 13 '12 at 7:26
add comment

Christophe Basso is somewhat of a PSpice guru when it comes to power supply modelling.

He wrote a tutorial paper for Intusoft that covers how to use the models.

It looks to me like you're not doing the full converter simulation - just the DC-equivalent circuit. The complete PWM switch model looks like this:

.SUBCKT SWITCH 1 2 3 4 {D=0.45 VAP=11 IC=0.8}
* A P C Control
B1 7 1 V = { V(4)*(VAP/D) }
B2 1 2 I = { V(4)*IC }
B3 7 2 I = { I(Vd)*D }
B4 9 2 V = { V(7,2)*D }
Vd 9 3 0
.ENDS
share|improve this answer
    
Ok, in fact I've looked at his tutorial and that's what lead me to the original papers - I was trying to understand where some of the theory came from. I know I've only got the DC-equivalent part, but this should still behave correctly on a DC simulation, no? –  Rupert Swarbrick May 11 '12 at 22:38
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.