Tell me more ×
Electrical Engineering Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for electronics and electrical engineering professionals, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Trying to prove to myself that the Q factor for an LRC series circuit is \$\sqrt{L/C}/R\$, but I am struggling with it...

My reasoning runs that the half power upper frequency limit is (ignoring the \$2\pi\$ factor) R/L, so half the frequency delta is \$R/L-1/(\sqrt{LC})\$ and the full bandwidth (assuming symmetry) at half-power is \$2(R/L-1/\sqrt{LC})\$

Then given \$Q=f_{res}/BW\$, we have \$Q = (1/\sqrt{LC})/(2(R/L - 1/\sqrt{LC}))\$,

which can be simplified to \$L/(2(R\sqrt{LC} - L))\$ which is similar to the correct answer, but not correct, with an errant factor of 2 and a stray -L kicking around.

Where has my reasoning gone wrong?

share|improve this question

1 Answer

up vote 4 down vote accepted

The resonant frequency is the geometric mean of the upper and lower half power frequencies, not the arithmetic mean you seem to be using here.

\$\omega_0 = \sqrt{\omega_l \omega_h} \ne \dfrac{\omega_l + \omega_h}{2}\$

That's probably all you need but here's some additional information just in case.

[UPDATE: upon further reflection, there's something else you need. The relationship between Q and BW you are using is a high-Q approximation. Deriving the genuine Q from this approximation requires a bit more than I've given below.]

For a series RLC, we have:

\$ Z = \dfrac{1 + j \omega RC - \omega^2LC}{j \omega C}\$

The numerator is of the form:

\$ 1 + j\frac{1}{Q} \frac{\omega}{\omega_0} - (\frac{\omega}{\omega_0})^2\$

Comparing these two forms, see that:

\$ \omega_0 = \frac{1}{\sqrt{LC}}\$

\$ Q = \dfrac{\sqrt{\frac{L}{C}}}{R}\$

How to see that the resonant frequency is the geometric mean?

Consider the product of two first order functions:

\$ (1 + j\dfrac{\omega}{\omega_l})(1 + j\dfrac{\omega}{\omega_h}) = 1 + j \omega (\dfrac{1}{\omega_l} + \dfrac{1}{\omega_h}) - \dfrac{\omega^2}{\omega_l \omega_h}\$

From this, we deduce:

\$\omega_0 = \sqrt{\omega_l \omega_h}\$

\$ Q \omega_0 = \omega_l || \omega_h =\dfrac{1}{\dfrac{1}{\omega_l} + \dfrac{1}{\omega_h}} \rightarrow Q = \dfrac{\omega_0}{\omega_l + \omega_h}\$

share|improve this answer
I thought your point about the geometric mean would make it clear so i accepted the answer, but I am still at a loss. I don't understand what the Z in the above answer represents - or rather how you have derived it. If Z = \$\sqrt{R^2 + (X_L - X_C)^2}\$ - how does that relate to what you have here? – adrianmcmenamin Jul 1 '12 at 21:55
Right, I get it now! Many thanks. – adrianmcmenamin Jul 1 '12 at 23:38
Great! I knew you'd see it! – Alfred Centauri Jul 1 '12 at 23:47

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.