Take the 2-minute tour ×
Electrical Engineering Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for electronics and electrical engineering professionals, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Many scientists are interested in developing supercapacitors, which have electrolyte rather than solid dielectric between the charged plates. In the field of electrochemistry, cyclic voltammetry (CV) is often used to determine the capacitance of electrodes (e.g., carbon-based electrodes) in supercapacitors.

I have often heard that an ideal capacitor gives rise to a rectangular cyclic voltammogram (CV). Can you please help me understand why this is the case? In other words, why does an ideal capacitor reach a constant current I as soon as a voltage V is applied?

I indeed see nearly ideal CVs in many literature articles (CVs which are rather rectangular with rounded corners). In other figures, though, I see relative deviation from "rectangles with rounded corners," in that I see abrupt peaks, spikes, or valleys.

For example, below I have plotted two figures from Khomenko, Electrochimica Acta 2005, 50, 2499-2506. Just very roughly and "hand wavy," what might be the qualitative reason for the "rectangle with rounded corners" behavior of Figure 8 (left) and the "abrupt peaks" behavior of Figure 4 (right)? Could it be that the sample in Figure 8 (left) is relatively unreactive toward apllied potential, whereas the sample in Figure 4 (right) undergoes redox (Faradaic) reactions -- indicating the presence of so-called pseudocapacitance -- when an external potential is applied?

CV

Please know that I am not looking for an answer specific to the article to which I linked. I am only asking this question in the context of basic, qualitative aspects of cyclic voltammetry. Thanks!

share|improve this question
2  
I'm perplexed by your use of the term "ideal capacitor" here. An ideal capacitor, in the context of circuit theory, is a fictional circuit element with the following I-V relationship: \$ i_C = C \dfrac{dv_C}{dt}\$. Physical capacitors approximate this relationship under certain operating conditions. I honestly don't know what "ideal capacitor" refers to in your question. Perhaps you would consider provide additional details? –  Alfred Centauri Jul 27 '12 at 20:21
    
@AlfredCentauri Thanks for your time. I am a chemist, and I am not extremely well versed in the physics and engineering of electronics. When I said "ideal capacitor," I was referring to a capacitor not exhibiting pseudocapacitance. Pseudocapacitance occurs when an electrochemical capacitor acts almost like a battery; Faradaic redox reactions occur between an electrode (e.g., carbon) and the electrolyte sandwiched between the electrodes. So by "ideal capacitor," I meant a capacitor whose capacitance obeys $$C = \frac{Q}{V}$$ and that does not undergo chemical reactions. –  Andrew Jul 27 '12 at 23:39
    
@AlfredCentauri I think that this means that I was referring to a physical capacitor, which "approximates $$i_C = C \frac{dv_C}{dt}$$ under certain operating conditions." In an electrochemical capacitor, (counter)ions in the electrolyte migrate toward a charged electrode, forming a so-called "electric double layer." Conceptually, an electrochemical capacitor contains two electric double layers -- one at each electrode. –  Andrew Jul 27 '12 at 23:45

2 Answers 2

up vote 7 down vote accepted
+100

A ideal capacitor makes a rectangular "volt-ammogram" because that's how capacitors work. Look at the equation of current through a capacitor as a function of voltage and you should be able to see this.

First, let's clarify what graph you are talking about especially since you are using a term not usual to electrical engineering. I've heard it before from electrochemistry folks, but it took me a while to realize what they were actually saying. You are slowly sweeping the voltage up from some start point to a end point, then slowly back down to the start point. The X axis is voltage and the Y axis is current. Since you are plotting volts versus amps, you mumble these two together into "voltammogram".

If for example a resistor was being measured, then the rising-voltage part of the plot would be a straight line with current proportional to the voltage according to the resistance. As the voltage was swept back down to the original value, the plot would retrace the same line it went up. Not terribly exciting.

Interesting stuff happens when electrochemical reactions are involved. For example, imagine a battery being tested as opposed to a resistor. The battery is being charged as the voltage increases, then discharged as the voltage decreases. It is not going to follow the same path forward as backward. In fact, the area inside the curve is a rough indication of electrochemical activity. Basically anything with "memory" is going to have a non-zero area inside the voltage low-high-low loop.

Now let's consider a capacitor being measured. The current through a capacitor is proportional to the derivative of its voltage:

  A = F V/s

Where A is current in Amperes, F capacitance in Farads, V electromotive force in Volts, and s time in seconds. So now you should be able to see that if the voltage is increased at a steady rate (V/s fixed), then there will be a constant current. On a voltammogram this means a horizontal line. Now when the voltage is decreased the same thing happens but the sign of the current is flipped. This is again a horizontal line but at some negative current (below 0 on the plot) whereas the first line was above zero. The current switches instantaneously from positive to negative as the voltage is changed from increasing to decreasing. The current suddenly changes but with little or no change in voltage, resulting in vertical lines. Put it all together and you have a box for an ideal capacitor.

share|improve this answer
    
One issue which is not specified is the nature of the driving waveform. A capacitor will yield a rectangular plot if the voltage is driven with a triangle wave, and a circular plot if either voltage or current is driven with a sine wave. If current were driven with a triangle wave, a capacitor's plot would appear as two front-to-front parabolas. –  supercat Jul 31 '12 at 20:55
1  
@OlinLathrop, I believe yours must be the correct answer. The OP asks "In other words, why does an ideal capacitor reach a constant current I as soon as a voltage V is applied?" But, from the plot on the left, we read "...(2 mV/s)..."; the plot is of current versus voltage for a voltage ramp of 2 mV/s. So, the OP is misreading the plot. The OP's question should be "In other words, why does an ideal capacitor reach a constant current I as soon as a voltage ramp is applied?" –  Alfred Centauri Jul 31 '12 at 21:00
    
@supercat: A voltammogram is produced with slowly but linearly varying voltage unless someone explicitly says otherwise. In other words, the restriction that there is constant dV/dt is understood. Note how the first example even says 2 mV/s. Under these conditions, a ideal capacitor will cause a rectangular plot. –  Olin Lathrop Jul 31 '12 at 22:55
    
@OlinLathrop: I had not encountered the term "voltammogram" to describe those plots; I guess that term is specific to triangle-voltage-wave plots? –  supercat Jul 31 '12 at 23:05

The kind of analysis truly required is outside the scope of chemistry and would be best handled in the careful hands of an electrical engineer. I'll give a brief attempt that exploits an easy-to-use circuit simulator.

We have to first think of an equivalent circuit that we can use as a model to determine its behavior. I suggest the following:

equivalent circuit

where my variable is R1's value for its resistance, which I shall set to 0, 10 and 100 ohm. If we were to watch this happen in time then we would see the following:

voltage over time amperage over time

Quickly converting these to Current vs Voltage and running two other simulations at different resistances and we get:

CVs

These results are due to setting up differential equations and solving them appropriately.

You can play with the circuit I made for yourself here.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.