4 Formatting
source | link

This will sound maybe stupid, but I'm amateur in electronics and I'm in process of learning :) I.

I have previously analysed till now some basic circuits involving opamps, diodes etc. Although

Although some circuit looks simple (only few opamps, diodes, resistors, capacitors and source (sources)sources), mathematics that descriebedescribe that simple circuit can be very complicated, especially if we want to calculate full response of circuit (not steady stadestate). I

I was wondering, how then some complicated electronics schematics are analysed? I mean there are devices contaningcontaining hundreds of components inside it, it would be impossible to apply some circuit analysis methods there (KCL, KVL etc), right? How

How important are those network analysing methods we are studying in school in practice (in repairing electrical devices)?

To clarify what I mean, lets look at one smpsswitched-mode power supply schematic I found on the web:

http://320volt.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/ice3b0365-atx-smps-uc3843-wt7525-circuit-diagram.png

Probably, professionals doesn't see there something terifficterrific complicated, but to me, it is very complicated. If one has to repair this device for example, which knowledge he need to have? If he start measuring some voltages, or tracing signals waveforms on oscilloscope, he must need to know firstly what he should expect in normal circumstances (when device is working), so he can detect exact problem. But how can he know that if he doesn't analyse circuit mathematical, which would be quite impossible in this case, what returns us to first lines of my question :)

This will sound maybe stupid, but I'm amateur in electronics and I'm in process of learning :) I analysed till now some basic circuits involving opamps, diodes etc. Although some circuit looks simple (only few opamps, diodes, resistors, capacitors and source (sources)), mathematics that descriebe that simple circuit can be very complicated, especially if we want to calculate full response of circuit (not steady stade). I was wondering, how then some complicated electronics schematics are analysed? I mean there are devices contaning hundreds of components inside it, it would be impossible to apply some circuit analysis methods there (KCL, KVL etc), right? How important are those network analysing methods we are studying in school in practice (in repairing electrical devices)?

To clarify what I mean, lets look at one smps schematic I found on web:

http://320volt.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/ice3b0365-atx-smps-uc3843-wt7525-circuit-diagram.png

Probably, professionals doesn't see there something teriffic complicated, but to me, it is very complicated. If one has to repair this device for example, which knowledge he need to have? If he start measuring some voltages, or tracing signals waveforms on oscilloscope, he must need to know firstly what he should expect in normal circumstances (when device is working), so he can detect exact problem. But how can he know that if he doesn't analyse circuit mathematical, which would be quite impossible in this case, what returns us to first lines of my question :)

This will sound maybe stupid, but I'm amateur in electronics and I'm in process of learning.

I have previously analysed some basic circuits involving opamps, diodes etc.

Although some circuit looks simple (only few opamps, diodes, resistors, capacitors and sources), mathematics that describe that simple circuit can be very complicated, especially if we want to calculate full response of circuit (not steady state).

I was wondering, how then some complicated electronics schematics are analysed? I mean there are devices containing hundreds of components inside it, it would be impossible to apply some circuit analysis methods there (KCL, KVL etc), right?

How important are those network analysing methods we are studying in school in practice (in repairing electrical devices)?

To clarify what I mean, lets look at one switched-mode power supply schematic I found on the web:

http://320volt.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/ice3b0365-atx-smps-uc3843-wt7525-circuit-diagram.png

Probably, professionals doesn't see there something terrific complicated, but to me, it is very complicated. If one has to repair this device for example, which knowledge he need to have? If he start measuring some voltages, or tracing signals waveforms on oscilloscope, he must need to know firstly what he should expect in normal circumstances (when device is working), so he can detect exact problem. But how can he know that if he doesn't analyse circuit mathematical, which would be quite impossible in this case, what returns us to first lines of my question :)

3 added 748 characters in body
source | link

This will sound maybe stupid, but I'm amateur in electronics and I'm in process of learning :) I analysed till now some basic circuits involving opamps, diodes etc. Although some circuit looks simple (only few opamps, diodes, resistors, capacitors and source (sources)), mathematics that descriebe that simple circuit can be very complicated, especially if we want to calculate full response of circuit (not steady stade). I was wondering, how then some complicated electronics schematics are analysed? I mean there are devices contaning hundreds of components inside it, it would be impossible to apply some circuit analysis methods there (KCL, KVL etc), right? How important are those network analysing methods we are studying in school in practice (in repairing electrical devices)?

To clarify what I mean, lets look at one smps schematic I found on web:

http://320volt.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/ice3b0365-atx-smps-uc3843-wt7525-circuit-diagram.png

Probably, professionals doesn't see there something teriffic complicated, but to me, it is very complicated. If one has to repair this device for example, which knowledge he need to have? If he start measuring some voltages, or tracing signals waveforms on oscilloscope, he must need to know firstly what he should expect in normal circumstances (when device is working), so he can detect exact problem. But how can he know that if he doesn't analyse circuit mathematical, which would be quite impossible in this case, what returns us to first lines of my question :)

This will sound maybe stupid, but I'm amateur in electronics and I'm in process of learning :) I analysed till now some basic circuits involving opamps, diodes etc. Although some circuit looks simple (only few opamps, diodes, resistors, capacitors and source (sources)), mathematics that descriebe that simple circuit can be very complicated, especially if we want to calculate full response of circuit (not steady stade). I was wondering, how then some complicated electronics schematics are analysed? I mean there are devices contaning hundreds of components inside it, it would be impossible to apply some circuit analysis methods there (KCL, KVL etc), right? How important are those network analysing methods we are studying in school in practice (in repairing electrical devices)?

This will sound maybe stupid, but I'm amateur in electronics and I'm in process of learning :) I analysed till now some basic circuits involving opamps, diodes etc. Although some circuit looks simple (only few opamps, diodes, resistors, capacitors and source (sources)), mathematics that descriebe that simple circuit can be very complicated, especially if we want to calculate full response of circuit (not steady stade). I was wondering, how then some complicated electronics schematics are analysed? I mean there are devices contaning hundreds of components inside it, it would be impossible to apply some circuit analysis methods there (KCL, KVL etc), right? How important are those network analysing methods we are studying in school in practice (in repairing electrical devices)?

To clarify what I mean, lets look at one smps schematic I found on web:

http://320volt.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/ice3b0365-atx-smps-uc3843-wt7525-circuit-diagram.png

Probably, professionals doesn't see there something teriffic complicated, but to me, it is very complicated. If one has to repair this device for example, which knowledge he need to have? If he start measuring some voltages, or tracing signals waveforms on oscilloscope, he must need to know firstly what he should expect in normal circumstances (when device is working), so he can detect exact problem. But how can he know that if he doesn't analyse circuit mathematical, which would be quite impossible in this case, what returns us to first lines of my question :)

2 edited tags
| link
1
source | link