2
\$\begingroup\$

I'm new to electronics and this is my first circuit. I have some questions about implementing ICSP in this design. This is a bit of a long post with quite a few questions so I'll apologize in advance for its length. Unfortunately I don't have a mentor who I can ping questions off of so any help is greatly appreciated!

enter image description here

  • I'm using an Atmel ATtiny10 microcontroller to drive an RGB LED.
  • The circuit is powered by two 3V CR2032 batteries in series which provide 6V.
  • The batteries are connected to a fixed-output voltage regulator which converts the battery power down to 5V for the ATtiny.
  • Three of the ATtiny's four I/O pins are connected to the LED's three anodes via current-limiting resistors (the fourth MCU pin is unused with an internal pull-up resistor enabled).

So far this is pretty basic stuff, and it works on a breadboard.

I'd like to add ICSP functionality so I can program the ATtiny in-circuit when this is moved to a PCB (for initial loading and later if I want to modify my firmware). Here are my questions:

Q: What is the best/preferred way to supply power to the ATtiny during programming (my programmer is an Arduino and not the expensive dedicated programmer from Atmel)?

There seem to be two options:

  1. Supply power through the existing battery+voltage regulator components, or
  2. Supply 5V via the programmer directly to the VCC pin on the ATtiny via a header/ICSP pin.

Q: If I go with option 1, do I need to be concerned about isolating the circuit from my programmer/Arduino? The Arduino is powered by a USB connection from my computer and I don't want to fry it. If I do need to be concerned about power isolation here, how is it done?

Q: If I go with option 2, I believe I'll have to put a Shottky diode between the regulator's Vout and the ATtiny's Vin to prevent current from going the wrong way into the regulator (i.e. from the programmer to the regulator's output pin).

A diode here seems to present a number of problems:

  • It adds an extra cost to the circuit.
  • It adds another part consuming battery power.
  • The voltage drop across the diode will cause the ATtiny to see less than 5V at its Vin, which is probably undesirable (due to clock destabilization).

Q: Are the concerns I just listed about the diode all valid concerns? I haven't designed anything with a diode yet so I don't have any experience with operational practicalities.

Q: Is there a different/better way to get power to the ATtiny for programming that I haven't thought of?

Q: Two of the pins used for programming the ATtiny will also connect via the resistors to the LED. What steps should I take to isolate the programmer from the LED?

I ask about this because I've tried to program it with the LED connected and the programmer usually hangs (you can see in the schematic where I connected the programmer, to nets PB0 and PB1). I had hoped the resistors between the pins and the LED would be enough to isolate the LED but it doesn't seem to do the trick. Disconnecting the LED allows the programming to succeed, however I won't be able to disconnect it once everything is soldered to a PCB.

Q: In a very general sense, what steps are usually taken by ICSP designers to isolate pins that have to be dual-purposed for programming as well as circuit control?

Thank you!

\$\endgroup\$
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ Note that ICSP is the name of the serial programming protocol for Microchip PIC microcontrollers. The AVR serial programming protocol is called ISP... Well for most AVRs. But the ATtiny10 uses TPI atmel.com/Images/doc8373.pdf \$\endgroup\$ – Colin D Bennett Oct 28 '14 at 3:13
  • \$\begingroup\$ And larger AVRs and AVR32s use PDI. atmel.com/images/doc8282.pdf \$\endgroup\$ – Ignacio Vazquez-Abrams Oct 28 '14 at 4:51
  • \$\begingroup\$ Is there a generic name for the technique of in-circuit programming? If so I would edit the title of this question. \$\endgroup\$ – par Oct 28 '14 at 5:11
3
\$\begingroup\$

A few things about your basic circuit before I address your specific questions.

i. Every IC needs a decoupling capacitor. For this circuit, that applies to the linear regulator and the microcontroller. For the microcontroller, as with most ICs, a 0.1uF capacitor between VCC and GND is typical. The capacitor should be as close as possible to the physical pins of the chip. The linear regulator takes a little more thought. Most regulator manufacturers will specify what kind of capacitors and what value to use on the input and output. This particular one does not, but they do provide a test circuit that should be good enough for your purpose:
enter image description here
ii. Every kind of linear regulator has a "dropout voltage" (VDO). The dropout voltage is the minimum difference in voltage between the input and the output. Your L78L05 has a dropout voltage of 1.7V. That means the minimum input must be: $$V_{INmin}=V_{OUT}+VDO=5V+1.7V=6.7V$$ Your 6V battery pack is less than 6.7V, which will not allow the regulator to regulate to 5V. Instead, you'll get something closer to 4V. That may not be a problem for this particular circuit, but you should be aware of that. There are plenty of linear regulators available with much lower than 1.7V VDOs.

Now on to your specific questions.

  1. It normally doesn't matter where the microcontroller gets power during programming, as long as the power source is clean and stable. So either supply the power from your battery pack or from the programmer itself. But only choose one. If you leave the battery pack connected while enabling power from the programmer, they may conflict with each other. Whichever voltage source is slightly higher will try to push current into the other one, which won't make either one very happy. My recommendation would be to power the circuit off the battery and not the programmer. That way you don't have to keep removing the battery every time you program the board.

One possible complication here is if your circuit contains high-current components that might activate during programming. It is likely the programmer will not be able to supply enough current to keep the voltage stable if there is a lot of current draw from elsewhere. In a situation like that, it would be required to use your own power supply during programming.

  1. You don't need to isolate the programmer when using the battery as long as the programmer's voltage supply is off. The only stipulation here is that the ground references of your circuit and the programmer are tied together. Otherwise, no special isolation is necessary.

  2. If you do use the programmer's power, putting a diode on VOUT isn't a bad idea, but in may not be necessary. Unfortunately, the datasheet for the L78L05 does not give a absolute max voltage on the VOUT pin relative to the VIN pin. However, I have routinely applied external voltages to the output pins of unpowered linear regulators without a diode in between without problems. Without a specification in the datasheet, it's hard to know for sure. But I don't suspect you'll have a problem.

  3. Yes, those are all valid concerns about adding a diode.

  4. If you use the battery pack for power instead of the programmer, there are no more concerns.

  5. Using resistors to isolate the other components from the programmer's pins is a common approach. However, you still need to be aware of how much current might be drawn from the programmer's pins. When a pin on the programmer goes high, the LED will light up. With a 100 Ohm resistor, a 2V LED may sink 30mA (\$(5V-2V)/100Ohm = 30mA\$). That's probably way more than the programmer's data pins can source. That's undoubtedly why the programmer is hanging up.

  6. Since you can't make the resistors any larger without making the LEDs dimmer, you can use digital buffers to remove the load on the programmer pins completely. Other types of components may need different types of isolation circuitry. But resistors and buffers cover most situations.

schematic

simulate this circuit – Schematic created using CircuitLab

\$\endgroup\$
  • \$\begingroup\$ Dan, thank you very much for taking the time to write such an outstanding and complete answer. This is a treasure trove of great information. I've read about decoupling capacitors but wasn't sure when to use them (always? ok!). I didn't know about dropout voltages nor that I could use a buffer on the programming pins. The Arduino says its pins can source 40mA each max (200mA total), but I'll try a buffer and see if that prevents the programmer from hanging. This gives me a number of things to do immediately to keep learning. Thank you so much! \$\endgroup\$ – par Oct 28 '14 at 1:50
  • \$\begingroup\$ During programming, the pins on the MCU will be inputs (high impedance), so the MCU isn't sourcing any current into the LEDs. It's the pins on the programmer that will drive the LEDs. The data lines of programmers aren't designed to handle any kind of load. I bet even a few milliamps is too much. That's what I was talking about in #6 above. \$\endgroup\$ – Dan Laks Oct 28 '14 at 2:02
  • \$\begingroup\$ The pins I'm using on the Arduino for SPI are GPIO pins in a secondary mode. At least one pin definitely sources current because the green component of the LED lights up and stays lit while it hangs. I can't find any reference material that indicates whether the limit is the same as the GPIO mode or if it's different when in SPI mode. In any event, your assessment makes sense and the current draw from the LED is obviously the problem--when I remove the LED it programs just fine. I'm going to try a buffer. Could you recommend a particular type or model so I can read about it? Thank you again!! \$\endgroup\$ – par Oct 28 '14 at 2:32
  • \$\begingroup\$ @par: A 74HC126 with the enable tied to nRESET and a weak pullup will allow you to drive the LEDs normally and shut them up when programming. \$\endgroup\$ – Ignacio Vazquez-Abrams Oct 28 '14 at 2:40
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ Digikey has a very large selection. Search for buffers and select "Logic - Buffers, Drivers, Receivers, Transceivers". On the next screen, filter under Logic Type for "Buffer/Line Driver, non-inverting" and "Schmitt Trigger-Buffer". After you hit apply, any of those chips will work. Although you may want to filter further based on your voltage supply. If you select "Cut Tape", "Tray", and "Tube" from the Packaging filter, it'll only show parts that have a minimum order of 1. \$\endgroup\$ – Dan Laks Oct 28 '14 at 2:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.