I have found only few volumetric displays for the kind of effect I'm looking for. They can be divided by two characteristics into two separate groups each: rotating or moving screens, and moving screens with a high refresh rate projector projecting on them or high refresh rate rotating displays.

EDIT: I have now come to the conclusion that projection-based rotating screens will work while displays/led arrays will not. Unless I can be finally be told whether LCD/other displays can be ran at few thousand Hz themselves, leaving the controller aside. And LED arrays are too low resolution for my goal (DMD chips projecting 600x600 pixels is fine, 128x128 leds is bulky for such rotations and low-res).

“Swept motion volumetric projected screens” seems the most promising. perspecta enter image description here

Videos are more interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9af-aX-UDDM



if you want a 24 Hz refresh rate of a volume (a 3d frame), you can rotate a 2d screen 24 * 180 times. That's over 4000 frames per second. 180 is the number of "slices" (2d displays) the volumetric display has. Its one for each 1 degrees. 180 because 180 degree rotation of a 2d display is needed to create a 360 degree volume:


Finding out how to control a 900 RPM motor is easy, displaying 4000 frames each seconds... not so much. From the various articles I've found on the internet I now have only a basic idea how to build a real volumetric display. I will link to relevant sites below. 3 DMDs/DLP chips (for R,G,B) have been used before each projecting 1 bit monochrome dithered image.

1) Perspecta. In it a "high speed projector" projects 198 768x768 pixel "slices" at 24 Hz on a rotating screen (rotating at 730 rpm).

The projector is a "5kHz MEMS-based".

The slices are projected at approximately 6000 images/ s by a group of three Digital Micromirror Devices, microelectromechanical systems- (MEMS-) based spatial light modulators (Texas Instrument, Inc. Plano, Texas).

A very simplified illustration of how it works:


2) “angled mirror” type: http://gl.ict.usc.edu/Research/3ddisplay/

Simplified illustration: https://i.imgur.com/2ITO7ta.gif

While I have found such MEMS ( DMD chips ) there is literally no ready affordable board for controlling them. TI and partners only sell boards for video projector manufacturers, 3d printing companies and similar and therefore are extremely expensive for what they do and what a university student or hobbyist can afford. Are there any? http://www.ti.com/tool/dlplcr4500evm http://www.ti.com/tool/dlpd4x00kit

3) http://masters.robbietilton.com/volumetric-display.html

This last project is especially interesting since it is using a relatively cheap $600 1440 Hz projector from Texas Instruments. But I am unable to contact the author. I have some questions and doubts that his project was successful (seeing no final video to prove it worked). For one thing 1440 Hz seems too slow, it would only allow 12 fps and 120 slices for each volume and I'm not sure if in this case either persistence of vision will work and 120 slices instead of 180 will provide a convincing volume.

And perhaps there are better options with other projection technologies? I can't find any mention of LCD projection.

What about sending monochrome video data to a out-of-the-shelf video projector or modifying such a projector to work that way instead of these expensive "evaluation modules" Texas Instrument sells?

So to sum up all my questions:
1) Is there a cheap ($600-700) way to project a monochrome video at few thousand Hz?
2) What can I use? Can a off-the-shelf video projector be made to work that way? How?
3) If not, can anyone help with building a control board from Texas Instruments DMD chips, DLP controllers and DM365 (TMS320DM365 Digital Media System-on-Chip (DMSoC)) which are used by the porfessional boards and are cheap by themselves?
4) Will the 1440 Hz $600 "Lightcrafter" with only 12 fps for 120 "slices" each second work?
5) Can LCD projector/LCD panel be used instead?

Links to articles on existing volumetric displays:





locked by Nick Alexeev Jun 16 '15 at 4:26

This post has been locked while disputes about its content are being resolved. For more info visit meta.

Read more about locked posts here.

  • \$\begingroup\$ The MEMS you mention sounds a lot like DLP chips the also have a micro mirror array. If they are the same technology then you change the color by changing the light source color. The drawback of dlp is that its either on or of , so to get different intensities you turn it on and off up to 256*3 times faster(once for every color) than your framerate, yikes! \$\endgroup\$ – Password May 7 '15 at 14:17
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ DLP chips can switch on the order of 1 to 10 kHz. They have to be pulse width modulated to get intensity variations. You may have to build custom drive electronics for the DLP chip to get the frame rate you want. \$\endgroup\$ – alex.forencich May 7 '15 at 18:02
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ It's all done by splitting up video frames into a sequence of binary frames. For grayscale, what they do is generate one frame per bit and then display them for different lengths of time. If a bit is set in all frames, then it will be set continuously. If a bit is set in none of them, then it will be off continuously. The overall framerate will drop when you do this. If you want color, what you do is split each frame into a red component, a green component, and a blue component and then either use separate DLP arrays or a color wheel. \$\endgroup\$ – alex.forencich May 7 '15 at 18:59
  • \$\begingroup\$ LEDs can do nanosecond risetimes, but you will have to make your own framebuffer system. Your cost per pixel is relatively high though. \$\endgroup\$ – mng May 12 '15 at 23:50

You set a pretty high bar by looking for both cheap and high performance in terms of data rate. The only way I can think of meeting those goals is to use an inexpensive FPGA dev board to do the heavy lifting. A $30 board that would do the job is here: http://parts.arrow.com/item/detail/arrow-development-tools/bemicromax10#22zM But this would require writing VHDL or Verilog code to set up the frame buffers on the FPGA board. Even lacking skill sets in electronics and programmable logic, you can likely hire someone to write the frame buffer driver in VHDL or Verilog and provide a circuit to take the Digital I/O from the dev board to drive RGB leds placed in a ring spun by a motor. This will likely be cheaper than the alternatives; particularly if you hire an engineering student that can take on the project as an assignment that they get a paycheck for doing. Or you might be able to suggest to a prof in an EE dept that you will buy a half dozen of these dev boards for his program if he assigns your pet project and copies you on the results students hand in.


Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.