Schematic for a lipo battery bleeder overcharge protector

OK, so I am building a 12v (really 11.1v) 10000mah lipo battery. I am going to use it on campouts to run things like 12v fans and car chargers and run other high-current devices that couldn't be run off of USB. Here is the problem I now have, how do I charge the battery?

My goal is I want to integrate the charger directly into the device and I want to be able to charge the lipo battery at 4-5 amps from a simple 12v DC power supply. This automatically rules out using using a simple 3S lipo charger from ebay because those can only charge up to ~1A. This also eliminates using something like an imax B6 because I want to be able to integrate the charger into the device, and an imax b6 is too big. Therefore I have decided I am going to design a DIY lipo charger.

The basic idea is this. I feed the entire lipo battery pack a CC/CV DC source (I will probably use a pre-built boost converter from amazon or ebay to do this) to charge up the battery to 12.6v. Then I use three discrete balancer circuits attached to each series lipo cell to simply "bleed" the battery down until it reaches back to 4.2v. Here is a terribly drawn block diagram:

As far as the balance circuit goes, I plan to use the TL431 shunt regulator from texas instruments to act as the IC for bleeding the cells down. Here is a scematic I have designed based on the high current shunt regulator noted in the devices datasheet ( if you google the datasheet go to page 26).

Here is the circuit I have designed:

Here is how the circuit is supposed to work. The TL431 has an internal reference voltage of 2.5v. So if I feed at least 4.2v into the TL431 circuit the restive divider will drop it down to 2.5v, the TL431 will then turn on and power a PNP power transistor (the TL431 has a max current of 100ma) that will then short a 22 ohm 5 watt power resistor that will draw around 200ma from the battery. I also included an LED in the circuit so I can know when an individual cell is being balanced (on another note, this is yet another reason why I didn't want to go out and buy a pre-made BMS or charger, because rarely do they come with indicator LEDs of any sort). If the cell goes below 4.2v, the TL431 will see less than 2.5v on the resistor divider, and therefore the TL431 will turn the power transistor in the circuit off, stopping the balance charging.

In my circuit the 3.3K, 1.5K and 1K trim pot are there to form a 2.5v resistor divider (the pot is there so I can fine-tune the trigger voltage). The 680 ohm resistor is only there because the datasheet said it had to be there. I have no idea what this resistor does so I chose a 680 ohm resistor for it and by the way I would love to know). The 220 ohm resistor is for the LED and the 22 ohm power resistor is there to be the dummy load to drain the battery.

Here are my questions I have:

1. Will this circuit work at all?

2. Can I substitute the PNP power transistor for a MOSFET and if so, which kind?

3. Are my resistor values correct?

If you read all this all I have to say is you are the real MVP. Anyway any help would be appreciated.

EDIT: as many of you have mentioned the resistor divider will draw under 1ma even when the battery is not being balanced. To solve this issue I have decided to use 4pdt switch to simultaneously cut off the balance circuits from the battery and cut off the battery from being charged. Unfortunently after checking the data sheet the reference current for the tl431 needs to be between 0.05ma and 10ma (so the resistors in the divider can only be so high) so that is why I chose those resistor values

• The balancing may not really be necessary if you start with identical cells and make sure they are balanced when you assemble the pack. In any event, only a little bit of bleed is needed. A BMS should also provide protection against over-voltage charge, over-current charge/discharge, and under voltage discharge. Those functions may actually be more important than the balancing function. I would also suggest adding a fuse, in case the BMS fails. I have wondered whether a TL431 might make a good balancer. But the voltage divider will drain the cell 24/7, and that will be a problem over time. Sep 29, 2016 at 4:44
• This circuit will drain almost 0.9mA constantly; you probably want to bump R1, R2, and R3 as high as reasonably possible. And consider using low tempco resistors since the circuit will heat up when operating. Sep 29, 2016 at 7:07
• With a BJT PNP you need a resistor from TL431 cathode to transistor base or you will apply fully on TL431 to base. | Using a P Channel FET needs no resistor. Available Von is then (4.2V-2.5) = 1.7V for FET Vgs according to TL431 datasheet. In fact TL431 cathode will pull to about 0.6V below Vref - but do not depend on it. A TLV431 is 1.25V and gives you more heardoom AND starts regulating at far lower cathode current. R! R@ R3 values can be much higher and thus reduce current bled via thgem . Sep 29, 2016 at 15:51
• ... | IF cells are very unbalanced on charge then chging stack to 12.6V may drive one cell well above 4.2V and :-(. Having clamps in place when charging safer as cells that reach 4V2 1st sit there. Maybe slow charge when any LED lights. Sep 29, 2016 at 15:51

3 Lipo batteries with marketing claim of 10,000mAh is actually just 18650 3.7V 3400mAh batteries. Most manufacture will recommend to charge 0.5C or below, so technically to charge it safe is just using max 1.7A constant current.

What you'll need now is:

1. 15V 2A DC supply
2. Lipo battery charger with variable current that charge 3 cells
3. A 10,000mAh battery pack that have 3 cell inside.

Note: Never charge 3 individual cell you get separately in series. Do not open the battery pack and charge separately.

Your proposed Overvolt protection circuit is really an amplified zener and it could be set to say 4.2 volt and work .Now to do this properly you must shut down the charger or drastically reduce the charging current when one of your bleed off LEDs starts glowing .You have chosen to use 3 cells in your battery where most others in my neck of the woods use 4 .It would be tempting to buck down or even do a simple low drop linear reg given that you chose 3 cells .If you want to use a fet instead of a BJT you will have to get a very very low threshold device to operate correctly in your circuit.A garden variety PNP BJT or darlington will work fine .Your resistor values are a plausible start but fuse like the comment from mkeith said.Remember that not all TL431s are equal.The TL431 is in the www.badbeetles.com website .

I've put some thought into this, and my recommendation is to use a separate 1s charger on each cell. In order to do this, the chargers should be fully isolated. AC chargers such as this one are almost always isolated (to keep 120v off exposed battery terminals) so 3-4 can be run off the same AC power strip with outputs hooked to batteries in series. https://www.aliexpress.com/store/group/3-7V-4-2V-Charger/1101221726_40000000457797.html