4
\$\begingroup\$

I have ruined a 3S LiPo 5400 mAh and I am unable to understand the reason. This is directly related to my earlier question which was about same battery.

I bought a new balance charger and put the battery on Balance charge on 3.5 Amps. When the battery was fully charged I checked its voltage with a Uni-T voltmeter and each cell was showing 4.3V when the charger was showing 4.2.

Battery was not hot, its temperature was being report as 25C and it did not puff at all.

I always try to take all the necessary precautions, and when I noticed that the battery is over-voltaged I immediately put it under some load (1/4th of normal) to drain the battery and reduce the voltage.

After some time it was within reasonable limits. This supposed overcharge remained for about 20 minutes.

Long story short, when i recharged the battery with another charger and then put the battery to use all the capacity was gone. 25 Minutes flight time was reduced to 5 minutes all in one day.

The internal resistance of cells as being reported by 2 chargers is not too high. 9mΩ 6mΩ and 5mΩ

I am wondering what happened? Is one time overcharge enough to ruin a perfectly normal battery? I know the battery is gone, but i want to learn from this so i can use the future ones better.

Everyone on internet keeps talking about low voltage but not really over voltage packs so i'm asking here.

This battery Never went under-voltage. Under load the cells at worst went to 3.6V

When I recharge the battery it reaches 12.6 Fine, and the charger reports as having provided 2700 mAh to it after starting at 11.1 V

What happened? Is the cause Lithium Plating? I want to learn lessons from this.

The numbers supposedly make sense, but the sudden discharge doesn't. As soon as you put the battery under load it instantly drops Voltage. on 1/3rd of the standard load it behaves like a perfectly fine battery.

The only other variable is that the temperatures have dropped recently due to winters. Now outdoor temperature is 11C and on last good flight it was around 25C

\$\endgroup\$
  • \$\begingroup\$ Where did you buy the battery from? \$\endgroup\$ – Andy aka Nov 19 '16 at 11:43
  • \$\begingroup\$ This battery came from factory with the Yuneec q500 4k drone and is out of warranty period. It was bought on Amazon in the USA \$\endgroup\$ – Hanky Panky Nov 19 '16 at 11:49
  • \$\begingroup\$ 4.3 V does sound very high, although the maximum if very dependent on the exact chemistry. Yes, overvoltage can damage such a battery. More accurately, it's putting charging current thru it when the voltage is high that damages the battery. One system I worked on, we were careful to never go above 4.1 V on any cell at any time. \$\endgroup\$ – Olin Lathrop Nov 21 '16 at 12:42
  • \$\begingroup\$ Did you measure/observe the capacity before you used the new balance charger? \$\endgroup\$ – winny Nov 21 '16 at 12:59
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ "with a Uni-T voltmeter and each cell was showing 4.3V" - what was the exact (to 0.01V) voltage per cell, and have you verified the accuracy of your meter? \$\endgroup\$ – Bruce Abbott Nov 21 '16 at 19:50
13
+50
\$\begingroup\$

I recall NASA discovered that Li-ions above 4.10V/cell tend to decompose due to electrolyte oxidation on the cathode (+), while those charged to lower voltages lose capacity due to the solid electrolyte interface (SEI) building up on the anode (-) with Lithium Oxide and Lithium Carbonate.

This was verified by Dalhousie University by Dr. Dahn who proved battery death is accelerated for the duration above 4.1V, while NASA knew that capacity was reduced to 60% with this method of reducing Vcv charge to 3.9V MAX. This enabled them to use Lithium Ion batteries for > 8yrs.

I later show how one major brand total lifetime Ah*cycle delivered was increased by 5x over the typical 500 cycle Ah rating.

The Depth of Discharge also affects aging rating. If you are familiar with how Mil-Std_HDBK 217 works with MTBF , they model the accelerated failure rate with formula based on stress factors. They may have a model now for LiPo's that uses factors for %DoD and CV voltage.

I would expect time, t becomes an exponential MTBF accelerator for both of these factors outside certain thresholds and varies with chemistry and quality of contaminants in the electrodes and electrolyte.

I once plotted the lifetime Ah capacity for one brand based on 50% min. DoD and CV max with available Ah for each cycle and number of cycles in life time, which I will show below, but I lost the source data.

Charging at ANY rate consists of measure Voc, measure V at pulse load , measure initial ESR and final ESR with CC to Vcv then Vcv to 10%CC then shuttdown. The risk here is that one cell reaches 100% SoC before the others and the balancer cannot bypass enough current. If Vbat exceeds 4.2 that means the balancer could not shunt enough current CC mode when current is max but "normally" can balance with declining Amps in CV mode. i.e. Balancers may not be able to dissipate enough heat for a 0.5C rate if this implies 5400mA*0.5*4.2V = 11.34 watts !! per cell balancer. It becomes a Pd and ESR of bat to balancer tradeoff and limitation when Cell mismatch exceeds 10~15%. ( assuming 85~95% of charge is not in CC mode)

Your Rs {9mΩ 6mΩ and 5mΩ} or ESR was excessively mismatched for balancer to function to protect cells during period of overcharge ~4.1 V

>Other Opinions

  • It is not the ESR that counts for the balancer to function within spec but the mismatch and Pd capacity of balancer , hence ESR of the balancer must be lower than the batteries

  • the tolerance of ESR mismatch is critical >2% needs attention

  • aging depends more on \$(Vcv-3.9)*Ich * time (minutes)\$

    • think of all the excess power during CV mode as self-heating accelerated aging

enter image description hereHigher charge voltages boost capacity but lowers cycle life and compromises safety.

Source: Choi et al. (2002)

  • Mfg generally ship at 2/3 SoC for longest shelf Life.

FWIW below with little explanation...

enter image description here

enter image description here

If battery capacity is Ah=C , left vertical axis above is number of C cycles of battery life achieved vs slow CV charge voltage and 50% MIN DoD. but discharged at any rate like 0.5C to 2C depending on DoD rating from 10% to 25% to 50% to 100%. ( I will try to find source info) Note longest lifespan is 50% DoD for recharge threshold. (Lenovo has a smart charge algorithm using these parameters)

The solution as I see it is to get a better charger with the following characteristics;

  • programmable CV, CC and %%CC for shutoff levels,
  • measures Rs or ESR imbalance throughout the charge cycle ( very important for self-heating) ( OR )
  • Commutates bypass current with flying inductors ( like a SMPS) ( flyback half-bridge between cells, rather than passive TVS or active zeners with excess ESR )
  • Computes actual Ah supplied to each cell and compares with estimated %DoD based on initial tests above (Voc, ESR) rather than to whole array or simply just ESR at end of charge.

Consider that in Car batteries with 850 A crank capacity at 7.5V each cell ESR must be balanced within 1% when new and when this mismatch rises , acid boiling in the weakest cell due to ESR*I^2 accelerates battery death quickly. Same holds true for LiPo's. The greater the ESR mismatch with a passive balancer, the greater risk to cell death can occur due to one cell reaching full charge while others still in CC mode.

CONCLUSIONS

  • Rapid Charge when cold, without individual cell temp = instant death
  • Batteries need room temp for operation and charging
  • Charging over 3.9V greatly reduces lifecycle more than loss in capacity

RECOMMENDATIONS

  • Monitor Bat. Temp. during flight and insulate Batteries with ~5cm styrafoam
  • Avoid charging COLD cells at ALL COSTS unless slow e.g. C/10 rate
  • Check Cell balancer for delta V during charging with mismatched ESR
  • Modify charger profile = 4.1Vmax
  • Add 10A pulses when charging by flyback method

FYI https://www.dal.ca/diff/dahn/publications.html

enter image description here

\$\endgroup\$
  • \$\begingroup\$ I suggest if you can program your smart charger, set CV mode to 3.94V and reduce CC for longer life and try to reduce flight time to 50% DoD with more packs and greater lifespan >> 1500 Cycles. High temp not only increases capacity but accelerates aging even more. Or use NiCad approach except lower ...10'C rise to regulate current down on any cell. as degradation is at least 2x faster for every 10'C rise above room temp \$\endgroup\$ – Tony Stewart Sunnyskyguy EE75 Nov 21 '16 at 17:11
  • \$\begingroup\$ it was a typo ... \$\endgroup\$ – Tony Stewart Sunnyskyguy EE75 Nov 23 '16 at 10:11

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.