1
\$\begingroup\$

I'm new to electronics and want to be sure that I'm selecting the correct wattage resistors for the circuits I'll be making but I'm struggling to understand why for instance 1/4 resistors are safe to use in many circuits using in some cases 10 watts.

I've found this 4w FM transmitter schematic as an example: http://www.diy-electronic-projects.com/p121-4W-FM-Transmitter

This might be a big ask, big would somebody describe step by step how that circuit operates and why we can use 1/4 resistors?

I'm also curious as to how the 2n2219 is only rated for 800mW

Thanks

\$\endgroup\$
3
  • 3
    \$\begingroup\$ The rating is for the power dissipated on the resistor itself, not the whole circuit. \$\endgroup\$
    – Eugene Sh.
    Jul 25 '17 at 18:03
  • \$\begingroup\$ how the 2n2219 is only rated for 800mW - because that how it was designed and made. A small signal switching transistor. \$\endgroup\$ Jul 25 '17 at 18:04
  • \$\begingroup\$ « Notes: The T2 wants refrigerator. » ... priceless :-D \$\endgroup\$
    – user59864
    Jul 25 '17 at 18:54
2
\$\begingroup\$

Many components will survive above the melting temperature of solder (which is kinda the point of reflow soldering). There is an old model of French car (I will not tell names, mostly because I don't remember) where the MOSFET which controls the turn indicators lives in molten solder, because the designers forgot all about thermal management. Driving fast on a speed bump causes it to fall of the board. You can resolder it (and add a heat sink this time), it'll still work.

I'm struggling to understand why for instance 1/4 resistors are safe to use in many circuits using in some cases 10 watts.

Take one 12V 12W lightbulb. It will draw 1 amp.

Put 10 of these in parallel. Each draws 1A, uses 12W, and the total is 10A and 120W. Same for your resistors, you have to check the power dissipated by each, not the total of all the stuff on the board.

I'm also curious as to how the 2n2219 is only rated for 800mW

Consider a component, there is a current I going through it, and a voltage V across it, therefore it dissipates a power P=UI.

Burning power heats stuff up.

However, the hotter it is, the better the air is at cooling it, because hot stuff heats up the air, hot air rises, which creates air flow (ie, convection).

A simple way to model this is: Temp = Ambient + Power * Rth

Rth is a thermal resistance, expressed in °C/W. If Rth is 100°C/W, then for every watt of power, the temperature will rise by 100°C. Many components will give you a "RthJA" in the datasheet, which means "thermal resistance from junction to ambient", this models heat flow from the active part of the device (usually a chip or a silicon junction, hence the J) to the outside air. If the component has a metal back (like a 7805 in TO220 package) you'll also get a RthJC (junction to case) which models the heat flow from the chip to the metal back, which you are supposed to stick on a heat sink.

Now, every component has a maximum temperature. Above that, it burns. For transistors it tends to be 150°C, for resistors a bit more. However, this isn't a binary choice. Heat makes stuff age and die faster. There is a kind of a twilight zone between "cool enough to last forever" and "hot enough to break down the day warranty expires".

As a hobby designer, it is VERY nice not to have anything that will blister your fingers, too.

Also:enter image description here

Notice the resistor looks completely fine! These little bastards are tough. The PCB though, not so much. You can even tell the PCB was mounted vertically from the way the blistering hot air charred it. As to what happened to the capacitor next to it (probably rated to 85°C)...

Anyway, reversing the above formula, you get: MaxPower = (MaxTemp - Ambient) / Rth

"Ambient" can really screw you. The higher it is, the less you can burn in a given component. Inside the dashboard of a car (enclosed space) under the summer sun, it can be pretty high. Same if the air filters clog up, or the cat sits on the stereo and fills the whole thing with hair falling through the vents.

Using resistors is a bit simpler, you don't mess with thermal resistance, the manufacturer simply gives you a max power rating. However, this corresponds to the max temperature allowed for the resistor, which is usually something like 200°C. In other words, if you dissipate 1/4W in a 1/4W resistor, it will be at max allowed temperature, so don't touch it with your fingers...

So don't use 0.25W resistor for anything more than, say 0.15W. Max ratings are maximum. It's always good to derate a bit (look at the picture above again).

Now, this is engineering, so we can cheat. The rating is given with the resistor laying flat on the board, in still air. If you solder it with long legs and let it stand up in the air, there will be a lot more air flow via convection. Also it won't char your board. So in this case, your 0.25W resistor could safely burn close to 0.25W.

If your board is vertical instead of horizontal, or if there is a fan blowing on it, then you also can get close to max rating. You might even go above max rating, and burn 0.5W (It will catch fire when the fan dust filters get clogged though. That's your problem).

Basically a 2W resistor is just bigger than a 0.25W, so it is in contact with more air, so it is better cooled. That's all there is to it.

Now, say you got a good old 7805 regulator with I=0.2 amps running through it. It has 25V at the input, and 5V at the output, so V=25V across it. P=V*I, it burns 4W. Quick datasheet check reveals that in free air, 7805 regulator in TO220 package has Rth of 34 °C/W. So it is 34*P = 136°C above ambient. If the inside of your case is at 50°C then your LM317 chip runs at 186°C, which is way above maximum.

In that case you look at datasheet, RthJC=3°C/W. You put an insulating pad (add 1°C/W) and screw the 7805 on a piece of aluminium like the back of the enclosure (Rth=unknown, but let's say 5°C/W unless someone puts a pillow on top or something).

Rth total = 3 + 1 + 5 = 9°C/W

Ambient = 40°C

Chip temperature @2W = 40 + 9*4 = 76°C

Much better! But you need a screw, and you need to think about it during layout, so your 7805 isn't in an inconvenient place.

\$\endgroup\$
1
\$\begingroup\$

Usually resistor wattages are chosen to be greater than the watts generated at the maximum sustained or average current that can flow through them under normal operational conditions. Each resistor in a circuit will have it's own dissipation and needs to be calculated individually.

Further, quite often resistance values are chosen to keep the wattages down into a range that is cheapest or commonly purchased by the manufacturer.

As for the 2N2219 rating. Ratings are typically based on temperature rise of the die with the case cooled directly to ambient air at 25C. If you try to drive it harder the die or bonding will melt. Heat-sinking can allow you to go higher than that but then you have to consider current maximums.

\$\endgroup\$
1
\$\begingroup\$

This is a poor design and T2 overheats consuming too much power for a small metal can. THe Beta also drops rapidly above 150mA which makes the output power much less than supply power probably 25% of 4W.

The Current gain in T1 and then T2 permits much lower bias currents thus, V*I=Pd is ok. But note the comment on link. T2 needs a refrigerator. Keep looking for a better design with a bigger transistor.

Always choose power ratings of final stage parts conservatively to avoid toasting the parts.

Then learn about thermal resistance. THe smaller TO-92 plastic transistor is 200'C/Watt in self heating not transferred power to output. THis one onlyly slightly bigger is the TO-18,, the bigger one is the TO-3 and TO-220 and SMD parts with large copper area heatsink can reduce size and cost significantly.

Although transistors can run hot enough to burn your finger a good design does not.

More on old TO-xx case sizes

\$\endgroup\$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.