0
\$\begingroup\$

I've seen a number of videos on YouTube where people have built a "Power Box" by putting a 12V deep cycle battery in some kind of weatherproof box with a charging equipment and added various switches and ports on the outside.

https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=powerbox

I'm looking into building one of these for my annual camping trip in the desert, and was considering using this for a battery:

Mighty Max Battery 12V 22AH SLA Battery
Volume: 7.13" x 3.01" x 6.57" = 141 in^3
Energy Density: 22 AH / 141 in^3 = 0.15 AH/in^3
Weight: 13.1 lb
Price: $44.99

However, I also already own a number of Anker PowerCore Li-Ion based USB power packs like this. Which have nearly the same AH rating.

Portable Charger Anker PowerCore 20100mAh
Volume: 6.5" x 2.3" x 0.9" = 13.5 in^3
Energy Density: 20.1 AH / 13.5 in^3 = 1.49 AH/in^3
Weight: 12.56 oz = 0.785 lb
Price: $45.99

Both of these batteries are about the same price and hold about the same number of AH. Yet the USB battery pack is significantly smaller, lighter, and more energy dense.

If I don't have any need for 12V power, and only need 5V/USB power to charge my camera, cell phone, and run some LED lights. Is there any point to even considering using a 12V SLA battery?

\$\endgroup\$
6
\$\begingroup\$

...hold about the same number of AH

But there's the catch! A big one:

The mAh rating for the SLA battery is at 12 V so that equates to:

12 V * 22 Ah = 264 Whr (Watt*hour).

But for the powerbank it usually is at 3.7 V (the nominal voltage of a Li-Ion based cell), almost all powerbanks use a 3.7 V battery and a DCDC boostconverter to make the 5 V output. The manufacturers want to advertise with a large numger of mAh so they use the actual battery capacity but "forget" to tell you that that number is at 3.7 V and not 5 V.

So at 5 V you will not get 20.1 Ah but (ideal maximum) 3.7 V/5 V * 20.1 Ah = 14.9 Ah. That exclude the losses of the 3.7 V to 5 V conversion. But it gets worse, the actual energy stored is:

3.7 V * 20.1 Ah = 74.4 Whr

So the SLA battery has about 3.5 times more energy than the powerbank.

So your assumption that the same mAh rating means they also contain the same amount of energy is false!

Combined with an efficient DCDC converter to convert 12 V into 5 V my guess is that the SLA battery can easily charge a phone at least 4 times more than the power bank. In practice that 4 times might even be conservative as down conversion (12 V to 5 V) is generally more efficient than upconverting (3.7 V to 5 V).

\$\endgroup\$
1
\$\begingroup\$

Number 1 reason to use SLA, you will be in the desert.

Be aware many (MOST) of the battery vendors on Amazon lie. Read the reviews carefully. Biggest lies are capacity and chemistry. NiMH battery packs are sold as Li-ion. And ridiculously high capacity batteries are sold at unbelievably low prices. When you receive the battery test its capacity immediately. Use Amazon Prime with paid return, batteries are costly to ship. Also FedEx, UPS, and USPS will not ship Li-ion batteries. I usually stick to name brands. Duracell for SLA and Panasonic or Samsung for Li-ion.

Is there any point to even considering using a 12V SLA battery?

There are many 6V SLA batteries. Just make sure they are deep discharge. Stay away from any batteries that specify CCA.

In the plus column for 12V is the number of products that work off a 12V cigarette lighter.

You can use high efficiency (~95%) 12V to 5V DC-DC Buck Step Down converter.

For the pro and cons of various battery chemistry (and a lot more) checkout Battery University

What does the desert have to do with it? Li-ion are heat sensitive and SLA are not.

enter image description here


enter image description here


enter image description here

\$\endgroup\$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.