I have a 20 liter electric storage water heater which has a 230V AC, 2KW electric heating element. The heating element is failing frequently primarily due to bad quality of water inducing faster corrosion of heating element. I decided to experiment with the current to increase the life of heating element. I want to limit the heating to about 80% of normal so that heating element runs at slightly cooler temperatures.

I have BTA41-600B 41Amp Triac available to me. This triac has sufficiently high current rating for a 2KW coil. Two options come to my mind.

  1. Buy a electric fan speed regulator. These are available cheap and in plenty. Open the enclosure, identify the triac in the circuit and just replace the triac with BTA41-600B. The question is will this work? I am an electrical Engineer and I do build small electronic circuits on my own, but I have never built a circuit involving Triac.

  2. The other option is to build a simple circuit with a preset resistance connected to the gate. But what should be the rating of this preset resistance?

There is one more question. Should I need to use a heat sink for this application?


1 Answer 1


Your electric fan speed regulator will have to be controlled by something, what will it be? Because I doubt the heater has something like that inside. Also, a gate resistor will only limit the command current but not the current through the device itself.

The way I see it, if you want to control the heating resistance's current (temperature) with a triac you'd have to resort to a dimmer-like circuit:


Do note, though, that you're dealing with \$ \frac{2kW}{230V_{RMS}} \approx 8.7A_{RMS} \$, which is quite a bit higher than your average light-bulb.

As for the heat-sink, it may well be the case. The dissipated power would be:

\$ P_d = V_{t0} I_{T_{AVG}} + R_d I_{T_{RMS}}^2 \$

With the catalog values and the previously calculated one:

\$ Pd = 0.85V \cdot 8.7A*\frac{2\sqrt{2}}{\pi} + 10m\Omega \cdot 8.7^2 = 7.41W \$

\$ T_j = P_d R_{th_{j-a}}+T_a = 7.41W\cdot 50\frac{^\circ C}{W} + 25^\circ C = 395.5^\circ C > T_{j_{MAX}}=125^\circ C \$

I assumed \$25^\circ C\$ ambient temperature, which means you'll need a heat-sink. After a quick math (involving some graphs), you'll need an \$ R_{th_{h-a}} \approx 13\frac{^\circ C}{W}\$ , which would be an aluminium square of 7.5cm (~3in) with a thickness of 1mm. Of course, conditions vary and this is an informative note, only. What thermal contact you're using, how you're mounting the heat-sink, etc, have an influence on the final result.

  • \$\begingroup\$ Very good explanation! You must be a great teacher! Are You? Best regards! Ing Eftim Stoyanov \$\endgroup\$
    – user78274
    Jun 8, 2015 at 16:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.