Electrical Engineering Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for electronics and electrical engineering professionals, students, and enthusiasts. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
I found a few specialized electronic parts that I am interested in buying from eBay and/or Alibaba. However, knowing that I will be traveling to China soon, I felt checking the purchase in person would lower my risks of getting a lemon. What do you think and why?
Thanks in advance.
I lived in China for several years. If you're looking for specialized electronics pieces (as opposed to consumer or computer pieces such as hard drives), you will probably have difficulty finding retail places to look at them. Most of the electronics vendors sell to other manufacturers, so if you don't have a certain quantity you wish to buy you will not be able to find many people to talk to.
What part of China are you going to? If it's Shenzhen or one of the other manufacturing cities in the south of China you will have much better luck than if you're going to Beijing, etc.
Don't the places you're shopping have a return policy for DOA or anything? If they don't I certainly wouldn't buy from them if you think there's a high chance of a lemon. So several questions:
1) What's the realistic chance of a lemon? I don't know what you're buying, but I almost never worry about lemons when I'm buying things.
2) Will you actually be able to test the components to check for lemony badness while you're there? Do you have a realistic method of doing this and how much effort is it?
3) Can you even be sure you'll be able to get them when you're in China? I'd take a sure thing over a chance, but if you have time you might as well look. Which brings me to...
4) Can afford to wait? I prefer having things now as opposed to later, and if you can't get it in China while you're there you're probably looking at a delay of at least a week ordering online thereafter.
What level of parts are these? Components?
The major concern with electronic components is counterfeiting, and counterfeit parts aren't simply leaded lumps of epoxy. They are often made on the same production lines, and can be QA rejects for being outside of spec by a bit (or a lot), and that specification may not be the most obvious or easy to test for (e.g. diode reverse leakage). Will you have some method to test a good number of them to determine their failure rate or specification deviances?
China is an enormous country; unless all your potential suppliers are fairly close, you're volumes are very high, or your schedule needs to be compressed for whatever reason, I'd just make sure that it's worth your time.
The only real advantage I see in getting electronics in person is that I can talk to people and see other products that I might not think to look at. When I order online I typically get only what I need.
I suppose that would make in-person shopping a slight disadvantage. :-)
fWell here are some potential problems for on-line shopping that I've noticed:
Transportation heavily depends on courier and mail services which could lead to unexpected problems and sometimes experimentation may be necessary in order to find the best way to have components shipped. One time I ordered a power supply and some components from a web-store. It turned out that they didn't have some of the miscellaneous stuff I ordered, so we agreed that the main part of the order be shipped via one of the leading courier agencies and have the rest sent by regular mail once they get the items. I of course paid for express shipping and 3 days later the packet was at my local airport. It took shipping company 3 weeks for the packet to travel from the airport to my address. First there were customs problems because nobody knew under which tariff category ordered items belonged, after that I got sent customs processing certificate for female underwear instead of electronic components so I had to complain to the shipping company and it took them 5 days to dig up my own customs certificate and after that some items were wrongly processed and so on and so on and so on. In the end, I got the regular mail back-order before the expressly shipped main order! Fortunately, I wasn't in a hurry, but imagine you have a project with a deadline and what ws supposed to take 4 days takes 22 and after that you haven't even begun to do any work!
Next problem can be shipping costs. For example Digikey charges $120 shipping to my country while I can get other stores to ship for $20. Of course, for large projects, this isn't a problem.
Next problem could be returns policy. Some stores won't pay for return shipping and sometimes shipping can be as expensive as ordered articles. Plus, there's the time wasted which needs to be accounted for as well. Of course, there could be problems with customs too.
Next problem could be details. There are lots of little things which can become a big problem and which sometimes can't be detected in advance from datasheets or information available on the website. Of course, this can be solved by sending few e-mails, but sometimes people make assumptions. I heard of a guy who one time ordered a large number of potentiometers. There are washers and nuts available as accessories for those potentiometers. In my country, potentiometers made by that manufacturer always come with a washer and a nut, but in the datasheet they are listed as optional accessories. Ones which he got from the Internet didn't have any nuts and washers, so he couldn't mount them and had to pause the project for some time until he managed to obtain the washers and nuts. The problem was that he assumed that he'll get the optional nuts and washers. Similar problem can occur if you’re looking for specific revision of a certain IC or something similar.
On the other hand there are problems with buying components personally too. Will the merchant have enough time to dedicate to you as a customer? Employees can be overworked and tired and could be misinformed and so on and so on. On the other hand, would you be able to make a right decision quickly enough? If you're traveling to another country, you're likely going to have a set of objectives which you need to accomplish and are likely to be under pressure to get everything done in the limited time period which you're spending in that country. If everything goes according to plan, you might as well have stayed home and made order over the Internet, but if something comes up, will you be able to manage the problem? AngryEE's list is a great example of that.
Next, you speak of China as if it's San Marino. Are you sure that companies you need to visit are in the area you'll be visiting? If you're going to visit several cities, time pressure problems may turn out to be even worse than expected.
I know that my answer isn't too helpful, but I least I managed to provide some food for thought.
