I've been using magazines and it works about half of the time. Thick sheets work better but they are hard to find and I must cut them to size. 

I'd rather just have something that works so I bought glossy yellow paper meant for toner transfer on Amazon. 

It didn't work at all, my printer can hardly get the toner to stick. Magazines are better, but they still are not good. 

Is there a type of paper that works consistently?