Skip to main content
added 301 characters in body
Source Link
Spehro 'speff' Pefhany
  • 422.9k
  • 23
  • 352
  • 952

Yes, there is no problem. Just connect collector to base and use that as the diode. No abuse involved. A diode, even an LL4148, is a bit more rugged than a diode-connected transistor but that should not be an issue here.

Here is the slight overshoot in the response with the LED open and a 2N3904 connected as I suggested (+/-10V input through a 220R resistor), 10ns rise and fall times simulated in LTSpice with 1ns maximum step size:

enter image description here

Yes, there is no problem. Just connect collector to base and use that as the diode. No abuse involved. A diode, even an LL4148, is a bit more rugged than a diode-connected transistor but that should not be an issue here.

Yes, there is no problem. Just connect collector to base and use that as the diode. No abuse involved. A diode, even an LL4148, is a bit more rugged than a diode-connected transistor but that should not be an issue here.

Here is the slight overshoot in the response with the LED open and a 2N3904 connected as I suggested (+/-10V input through a 220R resistor), 10ns rise and fall times simulated in LTSpice with 1ns maximum step size:

enter image description here

Source Link
Spehro 'speff' Pefhany
  • 422.9k
  • 23
  • 352
  • 952

Yes, there is no problem. Just connect collector to base and use that as the diode. No abuse involved. A diode, even an LL4148, is a bit more rugged than a diode-connected transistor but that should not be an issue here.