Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/StackElectronix/status/1268603429284388867
Became Hot Network Question
added 139 characters in body
Source Link
Marcus Müller
  • 100k
  • 5
  • 141
  • 262

I have a circuit where I am using a tactile switch to pull 3.3v down to ground and investigating debouncing the button. My relevant part of the circuit is

enter image description here

The 100nF cap does work here my signal has ringing that operates in the undefined region and causes a few false clicks. Increasing the capacitance to 1uf makes it worst. I tried using 10nF which was better. It reduced the ringing time but did not remove it. Image of scope trace below for 10nF.

enter image description here

This ringing is not really a switch bounce contact problem is it. What causes this ringing. There is capacitance on the power rail could it be that ?

My best results are with removing the caps entirly.

I know I can use software to solve this issue so it is not a big issue but I am using this as a learning exercise.

Link to my easyeda design

My https://easyeda.com/editor#id=|ef4b80af96044198b7d82f75bd8c5d92|89ca248051bd41989e7b93813d90190d|f77e195b2c46423883a8fe4397ee5066 design:

Top:

top

Bottom:

bottom

I have a circuit where I am using a tactile switch to pull 3.3v down to ground and investigating debouncing the button. My relevant part of the circuit is

enter image description here

The 100nF cap does work here my signal has ringing that operates in the undefined region and causes a few false clicks. Increasing the capacitance to 1uf makes it worst. I tried using 10nF which was better. It reduced the ringing time but did not remove it. Image of scope trace below for 10nF.

enter image description here

This ringing is not really a switch bounce contact problem is it. What causes this ringing. There is capacitance on the power rail could it be that ?

My best results are with removing the caps entirly.

I know I can use software to solve this issue so it is not a big issue but I am using this as a learning exercise.

Link to my easyeda design

https://easyeda.com/editor#id=|ef4b80af96044198b7d82f75bd8c5d92|89ca248051bd41989e7b93813d90190d|f77e195b2c46423883a8fe4397ee5066

I have a circuit where I am using a tactile switch to pull 3.3v down to ground and investigating debouncing the button. My relevant part of the circuit is

enter image description here

The 100nF cap does work here my signal has ringing that operates in the undefined region and causes a few false clicks. Increasing the capacitance to 1uf makes it worst. I tried using 10nF which was better. It reduced the ringing time but did not remove it. Image of scope trace below for 10nF.

enter image description here

This ringing is not really a switch bounce contact problem is it. What causes this ringing. There is capacitance on the power rail could it be that ?

My best results are with removing the caps entirly.

I know I can use software to solve this issue so it is not a big issue but I am using this as a learning exercise.

My easyeda design:

Top:

top

Bottom:

bottom

added 162 characters in body
Source Link

I have a circuit where I am using a tactile switch to pull 3.3v down to ground and investigating debouncing the button. My relevant part of the circuit is

enter image description here

The 100nF cap does work here my signal has ringing that operates in the undefined region and causes a few false clicks. Increasing the capacitance to 1uf makes it worst. I tried using 10nF which was better. It reduced the ringing time but did not remove it. Image of scope trace below for 10nF.

enter image description here

This ringing is not really a switch bounce contact problem is it. What causes this ringing. There is capacitance on the power rail could it be that ?

My best results are with removing the caps entirly.

I know I can use software to solve this issue so it is not a big issue but I am using this as a learning exercise.

Link to my easyeda design

https://easyeda.com/editor#id=|ef4b80af96044198b7d82f75bd8c5d92|89ca248051bd41989e7b93813d90190d|f77e195b2c46423883a8fe4397ee5066

I have a circuit where I am using a tactile switch to pull 3.3v down to ground and investigating debouncing the button. My relevant part of the circuit is

enter image description here

The 100nF cap does work here my signal has ringing that operates in the undefined region and causes a few false clicks. Increasing the capacitance to 1uf makes it worst. I tried using 10nF which was better. It reduced the ringing time but did not remove it. Image of scope trace below for 10nF.

enter image description here

This ringing is not really a switch bounce contact problem is it. What causes this ringing. There is capacitance on the power rail could it be that ?

My best results are with removing the caps entirly.

I know I can use software to solve this issue so it is not a big issue but I am using this as a learning exercise.

I have a circuit where I am using a tactile switch to pull 3.3v down to ground and investigating debouncing the button. My relevant part of the circuit is

enter image description here

The 100nF cap does work here my signal has ringing that operates in the undefined region and causes a few false clicks. Increasing the capacitance to 1uf makes it worst. I tried using 10nF which was better. It reduced the ringing time but did not remove it. Image of scope trace below for 10nF.

enter image description here

This ringing is not really a switch bounce contact problem is it. What causes this ringing. There is capacitance on the power rail could it be that ?

My best results are with removing the caps entirly.

I know I can use software to solve this issue so it is not a big issue but I am using this as a learning exercise.

Link to my easyeda design

https://easyeda.com/editor#id=|ef4b80af96044198b7d82f75bd8c5d92|89ca248051bd41989e7b93813d90190d|f77e195b2c46423883a8fe4397ee5066

deleted 8 characters in body
Source Link
Marcus Müller
  • 100k
  • 5
  • 141
  • 262

I have a circuit where I am using a tactile switch to pull 3.3v down to ground and investigating debouncing the button. My relevant part of the circuit is

enter image description here

The 100nF cap does work here my signal has ringing that operates in the undefined region and causes a few false clicks. Increasing the capacitance to 1uf makes it worst. I tried using 10nF which was better. It reduced the ringing time but did not remove it. Image of scope trace below for 10nF.

enter image description here

This ringing is not really a switch bounce contact problem is it. What causes this ringing. There is capacitance on the power rail could it be that ?

My best results are with removing the caps entirly. I

I know I can use software to solve this issue so it is not a big issue but I am using this as a learning exercise.

Thanks

I have a circuit where I am using a tactile switch to pull 3.3v down to ground and investigating debouncing the button. My relevant part of the circuit is

enter image description here

The 100nF cap does work here my signal has ringing that operates in the undefined region and causes a few false clicks. Increasing the capacitance to 1uf makes it worst. I tried using 10nF which was better. It reduced the ringing time but did not remove it. Image of scope trace below for 10nF.

enter image description here

This ringing is not really a switch bounce contact problem is it. What causes this ringing. There is capacitance on the power rail could it be that ?

My best results are with removing the caps entirly. I know I can use software to solve this issue so it is not a big issue but I am using this as a learning exercise.

Thanks

I have a circuit where I am using a tactile switch to pull 3.3v down to ground and investigating debouncing the button. My relevant part of the circuit is

enter image description here

The 100nF cap does work here my signal has ringing that operates in the undefined region and causes a few false clicks. Increasing the capacitance to 1uf makes it worst. I tried using 10nF which was better. It reduced the ringing time but did not remove it. Image of scope trace below for 10nF.

enter image description here

This ringing is not really a switch bounce contact problem is it. What causes this ringing. There is capacitance on the power rail could it be that ?

My best results are with removing the caps entirly.

I know I can use software to solve this issue so it is not a big issue but I am using this as a learning exercise.

Source Link
Loading