Skip to main content
added 26 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
ocrdu
  • 9.3k
  • 23
  • 32
  • 42

FETs in Pushpush-Pull Converter Keep Blowing, Not Sure Whypull converter keep blowing

I have a push pull-pull converter that uses BSC040N10NS5ATMA1 MOSFETs. I have also tried using CSD19533Q5A MOSFETs.

The FETs keep blowing at low power output (about 15W15 W). I am trying to get to 100 W. They fail to a short circuit. When I replace a FET, it happens again. Here is my circuit:

enter image description here

Things I have tried and verified:

  • Gate-source resistor: currently set to 10k10 kΩ
  • Gate drive resistor: currently set to 1 OhmΩ, have used as high as 3 OhmΩ
  • The duty cycle, turn-on time, and frequency are such that the gate voltage waveforms are not overlapping, so I do not think cross-conduction is the problem. Acutal duty cycle is still a bit higher than design duty cycle (40% vs. 30%), but the waveforms do not appear to overlap and the driver adds in about 40 ns of dead time.
  • The diodes in the snubber are very fast, part number UF4004.
  • I cranked up the gate drive and current as shown in the circuit and I am pretty sure I am fully turning on the MOSFET.
  • I also tried to use the FETs in parallel to reduce current per FET, and made sure to apply parallel gate driving, I see the same problem at the same power level (about 15W15 W)

I think the problem is that my resistor in the RCD snubber is wrong, but I don't know if it is too large or too small.

Any ideas?

EDIT 1: Inductance Measurementmeasurement

Leakage inductance is high actually about 4 uHμH, Primary inductance is actually 280 uHμH, turns ratio is accurate. Edited in image above.

EDIT 2: V(DS) and V(GS) Measurementsmeasurements

Initially I measured V(DS) using the RCD clamp values above, and I saw that V(DS) was spiking above 100 V at 15W15 W output, which is beyond the allowed value for the BSC040N10NS5ATMA1.

I changed the snubber values in the hopes that this would clamp V(DS). My measurement with C in the clamp replaced with 6.8 nF is shown in the photo. This was also taken at 15 W.

V(DS) is getting pretty close to 100 V. Also R in my RCD clamp was getting so hot that it looked like it was desoldering itself. A measurement of the capacitor shows that it completely discharges and rings during each cycle due to the low time constant.

enter image description here

V(GS) was a nice clean square wave on both MOSFETs with no ringing, foudnfound to be about 50 ns rise time.

FETs in Push-Pull Converter Keep Blowing, Not Sure Why

I have a push pull converter that uses BSC040N10NS5ATMA1 MOSFETs. I have also tried using CSD19533Q5A MOSFETs.

The FETs keep blowing at low power output (about 15W). I am trying to get to 100 W. They fail to a short circuit. When I replace a FET, it happens again. Here is my circuit:

enter image description here

Things I have tried and verified:

  • Gate-source resistor: currently set to 10k
  • Gate drive resistor: currently set to 1 Ohm, have used as high as 3 Ohm
  • The duty cycle, turn-on time, and frequency are such that the gate voltage waveforms are not overlapping, so I do not think cross-conduction is the problem. Acutal duty cycle is still a bit higher than design duty cycle (40% vs. 30%), but the waveforms do not appear to overlap and the driver adds in about 40 ns of dead time.
  • The diodes in the snubber are very fast, part number UF4004
  • I cranked up the gate drive and current as shown in the circuit and I am pretty sure I am fully turning on the MOSFET
  • I also tried to use the FETs in parallel to reduce current per FET, and made sure to apply parallel gate driving, I see the same problem at the same power level (about 15W)

I think the problem is my resistor in the RCD snubber is wrong, but I don't know if it is too large or too small.

Any ideas?

EDIT 1: Inductance Measurement

Leakage inductance is high actually about 4 uH, Primary inductance is actually 280 uH, turns ratio is accurate. Edited in image above.

EDIT 2: V(DS) and V(GS) Measurements

Initially I measured V(DS) using the RCD clamp values above, and I saw that V(DS) was spiking above 100 V at 15W output, which is beyond the allowed value for the BSC040N10NS5ATMA1.

I changed the snubber values in the hopes that this would clamp V(DS). My measurement with C in the clamp replaced with 6.8 nF is shown in the photo. This was also taken at 15 W.

V(DS) is getting pretty close to 100 V. Also R in my RCD clamp was getting so hot that it looked like it was desoldering itself. A measurement of the capacitor shows that it completely discharges and rings during each cycle due to the low time constant.

enter image description here

V(GS) was a nice clean square wave on both MOSFETs with no ringing, foudn to be about 50 ns rise time.

FETs in push-pull converter keep blowing

I have a push-pull converter that uses BSC040N10NS5ATMA1 MOSFETs. I have also tried using CSD19533Q5A MOSFETs.

The FETs keep blowing at low power output (about 15 W). I am trying to get to 100 W. They fail to a short circuit. When I replace a FET, it happens again. Here is my circuit:

enter image description here

Things I have tried and verified:

  • Gate-source resistor: currently set to 10 kΩ
  • Gate drive resistor: currently set to 1 Ω, have used as high as 3 Ω
  • The duty cycle, turn-on time, and frequency are such that the gate voltage waveforms are not overlapping, so I do not think cross-conduction is the problem. Acutal duty cycle is still a bit higher than design duty cycle (40% vs. 30%), but the waveforms do not appear to overlap and the driver adds in about 40 ns of dead time.
  • The diodes in the snubber are very fast, part number UF4004.
  • I cranked up the gate drive and current as shown in the circuit and I am pretty sure I am fully turning on the MOSFET.
  • I also tried to use the FETs in parallel to reduce current per FET, and made sure to apply parallel gate driving, I see the same problem at the same power level (about 15 W)

I think the problem is that my resistor in the RCD snubber is wrong, but I don't know if it is too large or too small.

Any ideas?

EDIT 1: Inductance measurement

Leakage inductance is high actually about 4 μH, Primary inductance is actually 280 μH, turns ratio is accurate. Edited in image above.

EDIT 2: V(DS) and V(GS) measurements

Initially I measured V(DS) using the RCD clamp values above, and I saw that V(DS) was spiking above 100 V at 15 W output, which is beyond the allowed value for the BSC040N10NS5ATMA1.

I changed the snubber values in the hopes that this would clamp V(DS). My measurement with C in the clamp replaced with 6.8 nF is shown in the photo. This was also taken at 15 W.

V(DS) is getting pretty close to 100 V. Also R in my RCD clamp was getting so hot that it looked like it was desoldering itself. A measurement of the capacitor shows that it completely discharges and rings during each cycle due to the low time constant.

enter image description here

V(GS) was a nice clean square wave on both MOSFETs with no ringing, found to be about 50 ns rise time.

Rollback to Revision 3
Source Link
SamGibson
  • 18.3k
  • 5
  • 41
  • 63

Fuck this site deleteI have a push pull converter that uses BSC040N10NS5ATMA1 MOSFETs. I have also tried using CSD19533Q5A MOSFETs.

The FETs keep blowing at low power output (about 15W). I am trying to get to 100 W. They fail to a short circuit. When I replace a FET, it happens again. Here is my circuit:

enter image description here

Things I have tried and verified:

  • Gate-source resistor: currently set to 10k
  • Gate drive resistor: currently set to 1 Ohm, have used as high as 3 Ohm
  • The duty cycle, turn-on time, and frequency are such that the gate voltage waveforms are not overlapping, so I do not think cross-conduction is the problem. Acutal duty cycle is still a bit higher than design duty cycle (40% vs. 30%), but the waveforms do not appear to overlap and the driver adds in about 40 ns of dead time.
  • The diodes in the snubber are very fast, part number UF4004
  • I cranked up the gate drive and current as shown in the circuit and I am pretty sure I am fully turning on the MOSFET
  • I also tried to use the FETs in parallel to reduce current per FET, and made sure to apply parallel gate driving, I see the same problem at the same power level (about 15W)

I think the problem is my resistor in the RCD snubber is wrong, but I don't know if it is too large or too small.

Any ideas?

EDIT 1: Inductance Measurement

Leakage inductance is high actually about 4 uH, Primary inductance is actually 280 uH, turns ratio is accurate. Edited in image above.

EDIT 2: V(DS) and V(GS) Measurements

Initially I measured V(DS) using the RCD clamp values above, and I saw that V(DS) was spiking above 100 V at 15W output, which is beyond the allowed value for the BSC040N10NS5ATMA1.

I changed the snubber values in the hopes that this questionwould clamp V(DS). My measurement with C in the clamp replaced with 6.8 nF is shown in the photo. This was also taken at 15 W.

V(DS) is getting pretty close to 100 V. Also R in my RCD clamp was getting so hot that it looked like it was desoldering itself. A measurement of the capacitor shows that it completely discharges and rings during each cycle due to the low time constant.

enter image description here

V(GS) was a nice clean square wave on both MOSFETs with no ringing, foudn to be about 50 ns rise time.

Fuck this site delete this question

I have a push pull converter that uses BSC040N10NS5ATMA1 MOSFETs. I have also tried using CSD19533Q5A MOSFETs.

The FETs keep blowing at low power output (about 15W). I am trying to get to 100 W. They fail to a short circuit. When I replace a FET, it happens again. Here is my circuit:

enter image description here

Things I have tried and verified:

  • Gate-source resistor: currently set to 10k
  • Gate drive resistor: currently set to 1 Ohm, have used as high as 3 Ohm
  • The duty cycle, turn-on time, and frequency are such that the gate voltage waveforms are not overlapping, so I do not think cross-conduction is the problem. Acutal duty cycle is still a bit higher than design duty cycle (40% vs. 30%), but the waveforms do not appear to overlap and the driver adds in about 40 ns of dead time.
  • The diodes in the snubber are very fast, part number UF4004
  • I cranked up the gate drive and current as shown in the circuit and I am pretty sure I am fully turning on the MOSFET
  • I also tried to use the FETs in parallel to reduce current per FET, and made sure to apply parallel gate driving, I see the same problem at the same power level (about 15W)

I think the problem is my resistor in the RCD snubber is wrong, but I don't know if it is too large or too small.

Any ideas?

EDIT 1: Inductance Measurement

Leakage inductance is high actually about 4 uH, Primary inductance is actually 280 uH, turns ratio is accurate. Edited in image above.

EDIT 2: V(DS) and V(GS) Measurements

Initially I measured V(DS) using the RCD clamp values above, and I saw that V(DS) was spiking above 100 V at 15W output, which is beyond the allowed value for the BSC040N10NS5ATMA1.

I changed the snubber values in the hopes that this would clamp V(DS). My measurement with C in the clamp replaced with 6.8 nF is shown in the photo. This was also taken at 15 W.

V(DS) is getting pretty close to 100 V. Also R in my RCD clamp was getting so hot that it looked like it was desoldering itself. A measurement of the capacitor shows that it completely discharges and rings during each cycle due to the low time constant.

enter image description here

V(GS) was a nice clean square wave on both MOSFETs with no ringing, foudn to be about 50 ns rise time.

deleted 2367 characters in body
Source Link
user224284
user224284

I have a push pull converter that uses BSC040N10NS5ATMA1 MOSFETs. I have also tried using CSD19533Q5A MOSFETs.

The FETs keep blowing at low power output (about 15W). I am trying to get to 100 W. They fail to a short circuit. When I replace a FET, it happens again. Here is my circuit:

enter image description here

Things I have tried and verified:

  • Gate-source resistor: currently set to 10k
  • Gate drive resistor: currently set to 1 Ohm, have used as high as 3 Ohm
  • The duty cycle, turn-on time, and frequency are such that the gate voltage waveforms are not overlapping, so I do not think cross-conduction is the problem. Acutal duty cycle is still a bit higher than design duty cycle (40% vs. 30%), but the waveforms do not appear to overlap and the driver adds in about 40 ns of dead time.
  • The diodes in the snubber are very fast, part number UF4004
  • I cranked up the gate drive and current as shown in the circuit and I am pretty sure I am fully turning on the MOSFET
  • I also tried to use the FETs in parallel to reduce current per FET, and made sure to apply parallel gate driving, I see the same problem at the same power level (about 15W)

I think the problem is my resistor in the RCD snubber is wrong, but I don't know if it is too large or too small.

Any ideas?

EDIT 1: Inductance Measurement

Leakage inductance is high actually about 4 uH, Primary inductance is actually 280 uH, turns ratio is accurate. Edited in image above.

EDIT 2: V(DS) and V(GS) Measurements

Initially I measured V(DS) using the RCD clamp values above, and I saw that V(DS) was spiking above 100 V at 15W output, which is beyond the allowed value for the BSC040N10NS5ATMA1.

I changed the snubber values in the hopes thatFuck this would clamp V(DS). My measurement with C in the clamp replaced with 6.8 nF is shown in the photo. This was also taken at 15 W.

V(DS) is getting pretty close to 100 V. Also R in my RCD clamp was getting so hot that it looked like it was desoldering itself. A measurement of the capacitor shows that it completely discharges and rings during each cycle due to the low time constant.

enter image description here

V(GS) was a nice clean square wave on both MOSFETs with no ringing, foudn to be about 50 ns rise time.site delete this question

I have a push pull converter that uses BSC040N10NS5ATMA1 MOSFETs. I have also tried using CSD19533Q5A MOSFETs.

The FETs keep blowing at low power output (about 15W). I am trying to get to 100 W. They fail to a short circuit. When I replace a FET, it happens again. Here is my circuit:

enter image description here

Things I have tried and verified:

  • Gate-source resistor: currently set to 10k
  • Gate drive resistor: currently set to 1 Ohm, have used as high as 3 Ohm
  • The duty cycle, turn-on time, and frequency are such that the gate voltage waveforms are not overlapping, so I do not think cross-conduction is the problem. Acutal duty cycle is still a bit higher than design duty cycle (40% vs. 30%), but the waveforms do not appear to overlap and the driver adds in about 40 ns of dead time.
  • The diodes in the snubber are very fast, part number UF4004
  • I cranked up the gate drive and current as shown in the circuit and I am pretty sure I am fully turning on the MOSFET
  • I also tried to use the FETs in parallel to reduce current per FET, and made sure to apply parallel gate driving, I see the same problem at the same power level (about 15W)

I think the problem is my resistor in the RCD snubber is wrong, but I don't know if it is too large or too small.

Any ideas?

EDIT 1: Inductance Measurement

Leakage inductance is high actually about 4 uH, Primary inductance is actually 280 uH, turns ratio is accurate. Edited in image above.

EDIT 2: V(DS) and V(GS) Measurements

Initially I measured V(DS) using the RCD clamp values above, and I saw that V(DS) was spiking above 100 V at 15W output, which is beyond the allowed value for the BSC040N10NS5ATMA1.

I changed the snubber values in the hopes that this would clamp V(DS). My measurement with C in the clamp replaced with 6.8 nF is shown in the photo. This was also taken at 15 W.

V(DS) is getting pretty close to 100 V. Also R in my RCD clamp was getting so hot that it looked like it was desoldering itself. A measurement of the capacitor shows that it completely discharges and rings during each cycle due to the low time constant.

enter image description here

V(GS) was a nice clean square wave on both MOSFETs with no ringing, foudn to be about 50 ns rise time.

Fuck this site delete this question

New image
Source Link
user224284
user224284
Loading
Fixed schematic
Source Link
user224284
user224284
Loading
Source Link
user224284
user224284
Loading