I'm reading AOE 3rd edition, book say below:
Here’s how the circuit works: the voltage divider R3R4 holds the (−) input at 37% of the supply voltage, in this case about +1.8 V; let’s call that the “reference voltage.”
So if the circuit has been sitting there for a while, C1 is fully discharged, and the comparator’s output is at ground. When you push the START button momentarily, C1 charges quickly (10 ms time constant) to +5 V, which makes the comparator’s output switch to +5 V; see Figure 1.39. After the button is released, the capacitor discharges exponentially toward ground, with a time constant of τ = R2C1, which we’ve set to be 1 minute. At that time its voltage crosses the reference voltage, so the comparator’s output switches rapidly back to ground. (Note that we’ve conveniently chosen the reference voltage to be a fraction 1/e of V+, so it takes exactly one time constant τ for that to happen. For R2 we used the closest standard value to 6 MΩ; see Appendix C.) The bottom line is that the output spends 1 minute at +5 V, after the button is pushed.
My question is:
- What is between resistor R1 above and the connection point below in Figure 1.38.
- If R1 and R2 are considered as a voltage divider, can R2 and C1 be swapped? Will the circuit be the same as the original one after swapping?
- In caption of Figure 1.39, my problem point is : R1C1 ≈10 ms in "The voltage VC1 has a rise time of R1C1 ≈ 10 ms."
For question 3 confused: I calculated that the product of resistor R1 and capacitor C1 equals an accurate value of 10 ms, $$(10^3)(10 * 10^{-6}) = 10^{-2} second = 10 ms $$ so I think it should be "The voltage VC1 has a rise time of R1C1 = 10 ms.", simply say, should use R1C1 = 10 ms, not use R1C1 ≈ 10 ms.
And if R1 and R2 are considered as a voltage divider, then the total resistance Rth of R1 and R2 in series is $$ \frac{(10^3)(6.2 * 10^6)}{(10^3) + (6.2 * 10^6)} = 999.8387Ω ≈ 1000Ω $$ The Rth ≈ 1k(approximately equal to R1 that its value is 1kΩ), then calculate $$ Rth*C1 ≈ (10^3)(10 * 10^{-6}) = 10^{-2} second = 10 ms $$
I see https://artofelectronics.net/errata/ say Page 24 modify change "1 ms" to "10 ms" in caption of Fig. 1.39, please see below picture.
- The last question is about: "After the button is released, the capacitor discharges exponentially toward ground, with a time constant of τ = R2C1, which we’ve set to be 1 minute", I calculate $$ R2C1 = (10 * 10^{-6}) (6.2 * 10^6) = 62 second $$ not one minute, because one minute is 60 second, so why author say one minute?