# When a AM radio wave reaches the antenna does the signal need to be in a closed circuit to be amplified?

This needs some explanation. In the diagrams of radio instructions I always see a single line from the antenna to the input for amplification. Let's use a vacuum tube amplifier as for example.

There is a single wire to the plate in the triode tube from the antenna and the electrons from the filament source are either attracted or repelled on their way to the cathode. I cannot understand how the circuit is complete since only one wire appears in the diagrams to be coming from the antenna.

Frankly I am having the same problem with trying to understand how this same tube can amplify a telephony direct current signal because I think of pulsating direct current with the voice intelligence as being a closed circuit. I wouldn't mind someone setting me straight on both. Thank you.

• Antennas often have a buried grid of wires, to provide the GROUND structure. CitizenBand antennas use the car's metal as the GND. Aug 14, 2017 at 16:21
• Think stray capacitance. Aug 15, 2017 at 5:53

## 4 Answers

When a AM radio wave reaches the antenna does the signal need to be in a closed circuit to be amplified?

Yes, and believe it or not there is a closed circuit. A simple monopole antenna uses ground as the return path - the incoming radio wave hits the antenna structure and a current circulates between monopole and ground and there will be an impedance too: -

The graph above shows what the electrical impedance of the monopole is and how it is dependant on the antenna length (height) and the wavelength of the radio wave. So, at about one quarter wave length the monopole looks purely resistive and that resistance is about 37 ohms (hard to see on the graph I understand). That's the impedance it presents to the rest of the circuit.

This means your radio wave is transformed into a signal with an output impedance of 37 ohms. But free space / air has an impedance too - it's $120\pi$ or about 377 ohms and this is due to the capacitance and inductance of free space i.e. the physical fundamental properties that dictate the speed of light.

So yes, there is a closed circuit.

Here's an example - if you wanted to tune into an AM broadcast at 1 MHz you could construct a quarter wave monopole but, that monopole would be 75 metres long and present an impedance of 37 ohms.

Or you could make a 15 metre long (0.05 wavelength) monopole that presents a capacitive impedance of about 1000 ohms (or 159 pF at 1 MHz). You would get more signal from the quarter wave antenna but, it would be really big and cumbersome then, to tune it you'd need a more complex circuit than the 15 metre antenna because that shorter antenna already looks like 159 pF and can directly connect to a coil to give good station selectivity. That's what the olde worlde crystal set users did.

Regarding your other question I have no idea what you mean so further information such as a circuit might be required.

• wow...now does a signal literally travel though the earth from the antenna to the radio? I will have to post the second question latter after I can see if your insight may also take care of that problem. Aug 14, 2017 at 21:44
• That's how antennas work but of much more significance is the prospect of wiggling some voltage on a transmitting antenna and getting a receive wiggle a billion miles away with no earth connection. Think voyager 1 and 2. Aug 14, 2017 at 21:46
• "You see, wire telegraph is a kind of a very, very long cat. You pull his tail in New York and his head is meowing in Los Angeles. Do you understand this? And radio operates exactly the same way: you send signals here, they receive them there. The only difference is that there is no cat."
– user
Aug 15, 2017 at 9:09
• @Sedumjoy 'does a signal literally travel...' usually no. Antennas must have two conductors, and a small piece of ground can act as the second antenna conductor. However, for "ground waves" at long wavelengths, the signal does hug the ground, and in that case the Earth-current does reach all the way from transmitter to receiver. This was how radio worked in pre-1910 era, with Marconi VLF longwave system, operating at well below 100KHz. (It's also how N. Tesla insisted that all radio must work. Earth currents only, with no radio waves through space.) Aug 20, 2017 at 23:14

Some antennas only appear to have one connection. In that case, the ground, or ground plane, is the other implied connection. In the case of something like a long wire out a window, the other antenna connection is ground. This is why you need to ground radios that receive with such antennas.

Some signal will be picked up anyway because there radio chassis will have some parasitic capacitance to ground. With such a arrangement, you will see a significant increase in signal strength after properly grounding the radio.

Some antennas contain both leads directly, like a dipole. In that case the current flows between the two leads.

Regenerative radio receivers often show single-wire antenna connection to their "input":

In this case, the radio is tuned to a frequency mostly determined by L1 & C1, and passed on to the very high-gain amplifying vacuum tube (12AT6). The ground symbol at the bottom is important. It would be connected to the negative end of the +150V DC supply.

The ground connection might also be connected to earth - a rod pounded into the ground, to metal plumbing fixtures, or to the electrical-box ground. It is assumed that this point is at zero volts, both for DC voltages and for radio-frequency AC voltages.
It is the voltage across L1 & C1 that is passed on to the amplifier input. Since its bottom end is at zero volts, and doesn't vary, the top-side voltage is significantly large. This particular regenerative stage has an extremely high impedance where the antenna connects. You might think of the "LONG WIRE ANTENNA" as a capacitance that probes in to the electric field of free space. A small signal here induces a large voltage at L1 & C1 resonant frequency.

This kind of antenna is sometimes called electric-field probe antenna. Here's an extremely low radio frequency preamp example. The antenna itself can be quite short, but must be physically placed well above adjacent structures, trees etc. Since the self-capacitance of the antenna is quite small, the high-impedance preamp must be placed right at its bottom end: Were you to model this circuit in a SPICE simulation, the antenna would appear as a tiny capacitor in series with a tiny resistance:

simulate this circuit – Schematic created using CircuitLab

• Your top circuit is OK as far as the regenerative RF amplifier stage, but the AUDIO OUT part makes no sense. First, it's simply connected to ground AC-wise. Second, even if it were connected to the RF stage somehow, the detector is missing. Perhaps R3 is meant to be between the 150 V supply and the tops of L2 and R1. There should some AM demodulation there because the average plate current looks like it's a function of the RF amplitude. Aug 14, 2017 at 19:23
• @OlinLathrop Good spot. Was concentrating on the front end, and didn't see the goof-up on the audio end. Grab a handy schematic from Mr. Google at your peril. Aug 15, 2017 at 10:42

I believe you have a fundamental misunderstanding.
As a general understanding, it is true that you need a closed circuit. This is most commonly taught by the use of DC circuits, which do require "visible" or "direct" connectors that show a completely closed circuit. However, as you move into AC circuits, you need to learn that even "incomplete" (open) circuits are (or can be) closed, via various capacitance effects.
You need to be aware that a capacitor is made of two separated conductors, and although they are physically separated, as far as AC is concerned, they are electrically connected. In other words, any time you see a capacitor (-| |-), as far as AC (or pulsed DC) is concerned, it acts as if the plates are shorted (-|-|-).

As far as the antenna is concerned, the top of the antenna is connected to one side of a "virtual capacitor and the other side of the "virtual" capacitor is connected to ground. Since the bottom of the antenna is also connected to ground (by various methods), a "closed" circuit is formed.

Using the circuit with the vacuum tube as an aid, if you use a "small" capacitor and connect it to the top of the antenna, and the other side of the capacitor to ground, you will form a closed loop antenna. This allows the electromagnetic waves to induce a small current in the loop antenna. This current then induces a voltage across the capacitor connected to the control grid of the vacuum tube. The grid and the cathode of the vacuum tube also form a capacitor, so as the grid charges and discharges, it controls (gates) a larger current from the cathode to the plate, thereby the changes get amplified.
The explanation for pulsing DC, is the same as above. The pulsing DC charges and discharges one side of the capacitor which induces a voltage on the other side of the capacitor... thereby the changes get amplified.

EDIT: After reading your questions once more, I detected another misunderstanding on your part. You say, "there is a single wire from the antenna to the demodulator input." This is not true. There are three "closed loop" circuits involved: 1 antenna closed loop, 2 control grid loop, and 3 plate output loop.
1 Is formed by antenna wire, ant. adj. cap C2, resonant tank L1 C1, and ant - ground (virtual) cap Cv.
2 Is formed by res. tank L1 C1, feed cap C3, and grid - cath cap Cg.
3 Is formed by cath - plate cap Cp, plate res. R1, output cap C5, and load res. Rl. (Note, several of these symbols are not on the designated circuit)

• you say the top is connected to a capacitor connected to ground and the other end is ground. they can't both be ground so is there only one wire going to the "demodulation" part of the radio? Aug 21, 2017 at 13:52
• @Sedumjoy: To clarify: I said the top of it (the antenna), is connected to (one side of) a virtual capacitor (and the other side of the virtual capacitor) is connected to ground and (since) the bottom of the antenna is also connected to ground, an AC "closed circuit" is formed. I will edit my answer to address your second question. Aug 25, 2017 at 5:17